Americanism
A uniquely American heresy
Table of Contents
Americanism, a uniquely American heresy, was condemned by Pope Leo XIII in Testem Benevolentiae Nostrae.
American Catholics must always be on guard against it, since they are constantly surrounded by and indoctrinated with liberalism, individualism, secularism (including Church-State separatism), and Protestantism.
Cause#
It’s no surprise that American Catholics spawned Americanism, when America was founded on liberal pro-“Enlightenment” ideals:
“The United States of America should have a foundation free from the influence of clergy.”
~George Washington
“In every country and in every age, the priest has been hostile to liberty. He is always in alliance with the despot, abetting his abuses in return for protection to his own.”
“It does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods, or no God.”
~Thomas Jefferson
“Can a free government possibly exist with the Roman Catholic religion?”
“The divinity of Jesus is made a convenient cover for absurdity. Nowhere in the Gospels do we find a precept for Creeds, Confessions, Oaths, Doctrines, and whole cartloads of other foolish trumpery that we find in Christianity.”
“The priesthood have, in all ancient nations, nearly monopolized learning."
~John Adams
“The proposed Constitution is, in strictness, neither a national nor a federal constitution; but a composition of both. The purpose of separation of church and state is to keep forever from these shores the ceaseless strife that has soaked the soil of Europe with blood for centuries.”
~James Madison
“Adam, if ever there were such a man, was created a Deist; but in the mean time let every man follow, as he has a right to do, the religion and the worship he prefers.”
~Thomas Paine
“I never liked the Hierarchy of the Church an equality in the teacher of Religion, and a dependence on the people, are republican sentiments but if the Clergy combine, they will have their influence on Government.”
~Rufus King
“In regard to religion, mutual toleration in the different professions thereof is what all good and candid minds in all ages have ever practiced … The only sects which he [Locke] thinks ought to be and which by all wise laws are excluded from such toleration are those who teach doctrines subversive of the civil government under which they live. The Roman Catholics or Papists are excluded by reason of such doctrines as these: that princes excommunicated may be deposed, and those they call heretics may be destroyed without mercy; besides their recognizing the pope in so absolute a manner, in subversion of government, by introducing as far as possible into the states under whose protection they enjoy life, liberty, and property that solecism in politics, Imperium in imperio, leading directly to the worst anarchy and confusion, civil discord, war and bloodshed.”
~Samuel Adams
- The Quebec Act
- The Act removed the reference to the Protestant faith from the oath of allegiance, and guaranteed free practice of Catholicism and restored the Church’s power to impose tithes.
- In Quebec, English-speaking immigrants from the Thirteen Colonies fiercely objected to a variety of its provisions, which they saw as a removal of certain political freedoms. The Act was one of the many catalysts that led to the American Revolution.
- In the Thirteen Colonies, the Act had been passed in the same session of Parliament as a number of other Acts designed as punishment for the Boston Tea Party and other protests, which the American Patriots collectively termed the Intolerable Acts or, in England, the Coercive Acts.
- The guarantee of free practice of Catholicism, the majority religion in Canada, was seen by colonists as an “establishment” of the faith in the colonies which were overwhelmingly Protestant.
Effect#
This Fatima Center article summarizes the Americanism heresy:
- Undue insistence on interior initiative in the spiritual life, which leads to disobedience. He condemned the practice of putting natural virtues (e.g. hard work, persistence, and frugality) ahead of the Cardinal Virtues and the Theological Virtues, which have a supernatural element at their core. We see this error among many of America’s deist founders who rejected miracles, the nature of divine revelation, and organized religion. Instead, they emphasized hard work, loyalty, persistence, human reason, and other mere natural virtues.
- Attacks on religious vows and disparagement of the value of the contemplative religious orders in the modern world.
- Minimizing Catholic doctrine. This is especially manifested when leading Catholics refuse to speak out in public, unequivocally and with conviction. It also occurs when rank-and-file Catholics, failing to enkindle the graces of their confirmation, do not actively live, proclaim, and defend the Faith. This leads to a tendency in American social life to hide religious convictions or to think that all religions are to be respected. How much worse has this gotten in the past 100-plus years since Pope Leo XIII condemned this trend!
- Minimizing the importance of spiritual direction. This again is rooted in the tendency of the American attitude that each person is the sole arbiter of his own destiny and he does not need the priest or another person to tell him what he should do.
- Maintaining the idea that all opinions should be publicly aired. The Church, on the other hand, has always [quite reasonably] taught that speech which harms morality and the truths of the Faith has no right whatsoever to be publicly proclaimed. Whereas false religions and atheists likewise assert the First Amendment of the US Constitution as protecting their views, in reality, God does not give man the right to assert any false religious views. Error cannot have a right to exist or to be promoted. Of all religious beliefs, only the Truth in the Catholic Religion is fit to be publicly taught.
For more details, see:
- This EWTN article
- This roundtable video
Testem Benevolentiae Nostrae#
From Testem Benevolentiae Nostrae (1899):
We send to you by this letter a renewed expression of that good will which we have not failed during the course of our pontificate to manifest frequently to you and to your colleagues in the episcopate and to the whole American people, availing ourselves of every opportunity offered us by the progress of your church or whatever you have done for safeguarding and promoting Catholic interests. Moreover, we have often considered and admired the noble gifts of your nation which enable the American people to be alive to every good work which promotes the good of humanity and the splendor of civilization. Although this letter is not intended, as preceding ones, to repeat the words of praise so often spoken, but rather to call attention to some things to be avoided and corrected; still because it is conceived in that same spirit of apostolic charity which has inspired all our letters, we shall expect that you will take it as another proof of our love; the more so because it is intended to suppress certain contentions which have arisen lately among you to the detriment of the peace of many souls.
…
The rule of life laid down for Catholics is not of such a nature that it cannot accommodate itself to the exigencies of various times and places. (VOL. XXIV-13.) The Church has, guided by her Divine Master, a kind and merciful spirit, for which reason from the very beginning she has been what St. Paul said of himself: “I became all things to all men that I might save all.”
History proves clearly that the Apostolic See, to which has been entrusted the mission not only of teaching but of governing the whole Church, has continued “in one and the same doctrine, one and the same sense, and one and the same judgment,” — Const. de fide, Chapter iv.
But in regard to ways of living she has been accustomed to so yield that, the divine principle of morals being kept intact, she has never neglected to accommodate herself to the character and genius of the nations which she embraces.
Who can doubt that she will act in this same spirit again if the salvation of souls requires it? In this matter the Church must be the judge, not private men who are often deceived by the appearance of right. In this, all who wish to escape the blame of our predecessor, Pius the Sixth, must concur. He condemned as injurious to the Church and the spirit of God who guides her the doctrine contained in proposition lxxviii of the Synod of Pistoia, “that the discipline made and approved by the Church should be submitted to examination, as if the Church could frame a code of laws useless or heavier than human liberty can bear.”
But, beloved son, in this present matter of which we are speaking, there is even a greater danger and a more manifest opposition to Catholic doctrine and discipline in that opinion of the lovers of novelty, according to which they hold such liberty should be allowed in the Church, that her supervision and watchfulness being in some sense lessened, allowance be granted the faithful, each one to follow out more freely the leading of his own mind and the trend of his own proper activity. They are of opinion that such liberty has its counterpart in the newly given civil freedom which is now the right and the foundation of almost every secular state.
…
It is well, then, to particularly direct attention to the opinion which serves as the argument in behalf of this greater liberty sought for and recommended to Catholics.
It is alleged that now the Vatican decree concerning the infallible teaching authority of the Roman Pontiff having been proclaimed that nothing further on that score can give any solicitude, and accordingly, since that has been safeguarded and put beyond question a wider and freer field both for thought and action lies open to each one. But such reasoning is evidently faulty, since, if we are to come to any conclusion from the infallible teaching authority of the Church, it should rather be that no one should wish to depart from it, and moreover that the minds of all being leavened and directed thereby, greater security from private error would be enjoyed by all. And further, those who avail themselves of such a way of reasoning seem to depart seriously from the over-ruling wisdom of the Most High-which wisdom, since it was pleased to set forth by most solemn decision the authority and supreme teaching rights of this Apostolic See-willed that decision precisely in order to safeguard the minds of the Church’s children from the dangers of these present times.
These dangers, viz., the confounding of license with liberty, the passion for discussing and pouring contempt upon any possible subject, the assumed right to hold whatever opinions one pleases upon any subject and to set them forth in print to the world, have so wrapped minds in darkness that there is now a greater need of the Church’s teaching office than ever before, lest people become unmindful both of conscience and of duty.
We, indeed, have no thought of rejecting everything that modern industry and study has produced; so far from it that we welcome to the patrimony of truth and to an ever-widening scope of public well-being whatsoever helps toward the progress of learning and virtue. Yet all this, to be of any solid benefit, nay, to have a real existence and growth, can only be on the condition of recognizing the wisdom and authority of the Church.