# Contrarian Contagion

- Date: 2024-05-18
- URL: https://vericaritas.pages.dev/blog/contrarian-contagion/
- Summary: An epidemic of contrarianism

## Agree To Disagree

There’s an epidemic of [contrarianism](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/contrarian) and [disagreement](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agreeableness),

How often in public and private discourse do you notice people disagreeing seemingly for the sake of disagreeing? When truth is truth, and truth is spoken, what is there to do but agree or better express it? If someone is in error, then yes it’s time for correction. We should be cooperating ([iron sharpening iron](https://catenabible.com/bible/dra/prv/27#v17)) to discover and better express the truth.

Everyone assumes the worst in what others say. The root of this contagion is a lack of charity. Which is why you have to prepend or append every statement with a litany of qualifiers so people don’t assume you’re either Satan incarnate or that you’ve been [living under a rock](https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/living+under+a+rock) since birth. You can’t express your idea unless it’s under 5 seconds, and also includes all knowledge of human history and all of theology and all of science and all the other edge cases.

It really is no wonder that so many Catholics are sometimes [skeptical](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skepticism) of the faith itself, or what the Church teaches, or [slander](https://vericaritas.pages.dev/blog/papal-protest/index.md) the Pope by uncharitably interpreting what he says or teaches. If people argued with Jesus, Truth incarnate, it should be no surprise people argue for the sake of arguing, even against truth.

> And the Pharisees came forth, and began to question with him, asking him a sign from heaven, tempting him.
>
> ~[Mark 8:11](https://catenabible.com/bible/dra/mk/8#v11)

> Pilate therefore said to him: Art thou a king then? Jesus answered: Thou sayest that I am a king. For this was I born, and for this came I into the world; that I should give testimony to the truth. Every one that is of the truth, heareth my voice. Pilate saith to him: What is truth?
>
> ~[John 18:37-38](https://catenabible.com/bible/dra/jn/18#v37)

> Know also this, that, in the last days, shall come dangerous times. Men shall be lovers of themselves, covetous, haughty, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, ungrateful, wicked, Without affection, without peace, slanderers, incontinent, unmerciful, without kindness, Traitors, stubborn, puffed up, and lovers of pleasures more than of God: Having an appearance indeed of godliness, but denying the power thereof. Now these avoid. For of these sort are they who creep into houses, and lead captive silly women laden with sins, who are led away with divers desires: Ever learning, and never attaining to the knowledge of the truth.
>
> ~[2 Timothy 3:1-7](https://catenabible.com/bible/dra/2tm/3#v1)

## Modern Outbreak

Today’s contrarian epidemic could be blamed on YouTube and social media personalities. There’s an outbreak of outrage culture. Nobody wants to follow someone who is always agreeable and boring. They want tension, drama, and conflict; and being disagreeable creates that. Disagreeable people also _seem_ smarter. Surely they know something others don’t? So being disagreeable makes you popular and look smarter. Before social media took off, you could see this on mainstream media, especially the news where you would see a cacophony of 8 faces all simultaneously disagreeing.

> And avoid foolish and unlearned questions, knowing that they beget strifes. But the servant of the Lord must not wrangle: but be mild towards all men, apt to teach, patient,
>
> ~[2 Timothy 2:23-24](https://catenabible.com/bible/dra/2tm/2#v23)

> Let no evil speech proceed from your mouth; but that which is good, to the edification of faith, that it may administer grace to the hearers.
>
> ~[Ephesians 4:29](https://catenabible.com/bible/dra/eph/4#v29)

> Now the works of the flesh are manifest, which are fornication, uncleanness, immodesty, luxury, Idolatry, witchcrafts, enmities, contentions, emulations, wraths, quarrels, [**dissensions**](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/dissension), sects, Envies, murders, drunkenness, revellings, and such like. Of the which I foretell you, as I have foretold to you, that they who do such things shall not obtain the kingdom of God.
>
> ~[Galatians 5:19-21](https://catenabible.com/bible/dra/gal/5#v19)

## How To Dispute

Fr. Philip Powell, O.P. [explains the Old School Dominican style of disputation](https://hancaquam.blogspot.com/2014/02/disputation-dominican-style.html):

> the Dominican method of disputation (in breve)...
>
> Early Dominican disputation was done in public, usually in universities for the benefit of students learning the crafts of philosophy and theology. The Master (professor) would give a lecture on some topic and then take questions from the students and other Masters. Once asked, the question would be answered first with a list of objections to the Master’s real answer. So, if the Master’s real answer was “Yes,” he would begin by stating what all the “No” answers would seem to be. These are presented in the _Summa theologiae_ as the “_videtur_” or “it would seem that.”
>
> After this, the Master would provide a _sed contra_, or a “to the contrary,” a general answer to the objections that served to lay the foundation for his own answer to the original question. The _sed contra_ was usually a quotation from scripture, a well-respected theologian/philosopher, or saint that directly or indirectly touched on the question.
>
> Once the _sed contra_ is announced, the Master would answer with a _respondeo_, the “I respond that.” Here he pulls on the foundational principles taught to his students, employing basic logic, metaphysics, common sense, and additional authoritative sources.
>
> In the _respondeo_, the Master would use a peculiarly scholastic technique in arguing his point. Summarized the technique is: “_Never deny, rarely affirm, always distinguish_.” Thus, the scholastics’ reputation for “multiplying distinctions.”
>
> After the _respondeo_, the Master would then apply his answer to each objection (the _videtur_) in a reply and show why each was incorrect given the _sed contra_ and the logic of the _respondeo_.

> Break down of the “_Never deny, rarely affirm, always distinguish_”
>
> _Never deny:_ this principle presupposes charity in requiring the responder to take seriously the objections made to any answer he might give; that is, by never outright denying a conclusion, the Master presumes the good will of the objector and averts any attacks on the person. By disallowing the outright denial of an opponent’s premise or conclusion, the ’never deny’ pushes us in charity to recognize that even an assertion erroneous on the whole may contain some partial truth. The next two steps in the method assure us of ferreting out whatever truth might be found error. (NB. This technique also tends to kill in its cradle the all-too-often virulent disease we call “flaming”).
>
> _Rarely affirm:_ this principle frees the Master from the traps in the objections that might inexorably lead him to conclude that the objection is correct. It also serves to push the argument beyond merely polite agreement and force the debaters to explore areas of disagreement that could lead to a better answer.
>
> _Always distinguish:_ this principle allows the Master to accomplish the first two principles while still giving him plenty of room to disagree with the objections. By requiring the Master to carefully parse his words, this step in the argument recognizes the limits of language and logic when discussing any truth and acknowledges that there is some hope of finding better and better definitions.

> So, in practice, you will hear those who use this method say things like, “If by X, you mean Y, then X” or “I would distinguish between X and Y” or “You are right to say X, but X does not necessarily entail Y” and so on. The goal is to parse proper distinctions with charity until there is some clarity with regard to the use of terms and their place in the argument.
>
> I should add here another good principle of logic: “Where there is no difference, there can be no distinction;” that is, any distinction between X and Y must be based on a real difference between X and Y. For example, all teachers have heard some version of the following: “But I didn’t plagiarize my paper, I just borrowed my roommate’s paper and put my name on it.”

[This Studium to Studio episode](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YfNuw4G6zuo) on Disputation goes into more detail on “disputatio” and the “charitable conversation in search of Truth.”

## Charity

From the [Catechism of the Catholic Church](https://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a8.htm#2478):

> 2478 To avoid rash judgment, everyone should be careful to interpret insofar as possible his neighbor’s thoughts, words, and deeds in a favorable way:
>
> Every good Christian ought to be more ready to give a favorable interpretation to another’s statement than to condemn it. But if he cannot do so, let him ask how the other understands it. And if the latter understands it badly, let the former correct him with love. If that does not suffice, let the Christian try all suitable ways to bring the other to a correct interpretation so that he may be saved.
>
> ...
>
> 2496 The means of social communication (especially the mass media) can give rise to a certain passivity among users, making them less than vigilant consumers of what is said or shown. Users should practice moderation and discipline in their approach to the mass media. They will want to form enlightened and correct consciences the more easily to resist unwholesome influences.
