Disprove Evil with Love
And a little bit of luck
Table of Contents
Privation Theory of Evil#
Can you disprove evil with love, and a little bit of luck?
I’ve been re-reading Confessions by Saint Augustine, and wanted to think about the privation theory of evil before our new Augustinian Pope Leo XIV likely teaches further on the subject.
There is no possible source of evil except good.
~(Contra Julian. i, 9), by Saint Augustine
Good vs Evil#
Good is anything that conforms to God’s perfect will.
Evil is anything that falls short of that.
And Jesus said to him, Why callest thou me good? None is good but one, that is God.
The Problem of Evil#
You’ve likely seen this argument:
- If God exists, then God is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect.
- If God is omnipotent, then God has the power to eliminate all evil.
- If God is omniscient, then God knows when evil exists.
- If God is morally perfect, then God has the desire to eliminate all evil.
- Evil exists.
- If evil exists and God exists, then either God doesn’t have the power to eliminate all evil, or doesn’t know when evil exists, or doesn’t have the desire to eliminate all evil.
- Therefore, God doesn’t exist.
What if evil ultimately does not exist, and this argument breaks at its hinge?
(To be clear up front, there’s a distinction between “immediate” and “ultimate” sense, which is detailed later.)
Love#
Saint Augustine, in Confessions, ties existence to goodness, and explains that if a thing exists then it must be good, since our all-good God allows it to exist.
Taking it further, let’s add in God’s love:
Does everything that exists come from God?
- Yes, according to the Bible: (In the beginning God created heaven, and earth), “And God saw all the things that he had made, and they were very good.”
- Yes, according the Nicene Creed: “I believe in one God, the Father almighty, maker of heaven and earth, of all things visible and invisible”.
Does God only create things that are good?
- Yes, according to the Catechism: “God is in no way, directly or indirectly, the cause of moral evil.”
Does God love everything that exists?
- Yes, insofar as they exist.
Does God love only what is good?
- Yes, because God is goodness itself.
Therefore, everything that exists at every moment is good, since:
- Everything that exists comes from God.
- God only creates good.
- God loves everything that exists.
- God only loves what is good.
Therefore, evil ultimately does not exist.
Luck#
Luck is another example of something that ultimately does not exist.
Luck, or chance or probability, can be good luck or bad luck, which is to say it’s the ignorance of future events being good or bad. Winning the lottery can be seen as good luck. Getting into a car accident as bad luck.
But does luck ultimately exist?
Does God know everything that will happen, even in the future? Yes, according to the Catechism of the Catholic Church:
600 To God, all moments of time are present in their immediacy. When therefore he establishes his eternal plan of “predestination”, he includes in it each person’s free response to his grace: “In this city, in fact, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, with the Gentiles and the peoples of Israel, gathered together against your holy servant Jesus, whom you anointed, to do whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place.” For the sake of accomplishing his plan of salvation, God permitted the acts that flowed from their blindness.
Chance, probability, and therefore luck, does not ultimately exist to God.
Luck, chance, and probability exists to us humans only because we lack the knowledge that only God has.
Immediate vs Ultimate#
What is meant by “ultimately exist”?
There’s a sort of relativism here, as in there’s partial truth relative to us creatures that live in time, and the entire Truth relative to God who alone knows all and lives outside-of-time.
To us created beings that live in time, evil and luck are real, and so in an immediate sense they are indeed real. Jesus taught and the Church teaches us about evil, so it’s safe to say that, in a sense, evil is real. One obvious example of evil is sin.
But do evil and luck truly exist? As in, do they ultimately exist in the divine sense, in the mind of God?
This Catechism paragraph sums it up perfectly:
312 In time we can discover that God in his almighty providence can bring a good from the consequences of an evil, even a moral evil, caused by his creatures: “It was not you”, said Joseph to his brothers, “who sent me here, but God. . . You meant evil against me; but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive.” From the greatest moral evil ever committed - the rejection and murder of God’s only Son, caused by the sins of all men - God, by his grace that “abounded all the more”, brought the greatest of goods: the glorification of Christ and our redemption. But for all that, evil never becomes a good.
In the immediate sense, what Joseph’s brothers did was evil.
In the ultimate sense, a greater good came from it.
This idea of immediate sense versus ultimate sense, can be applied to many other things. The dividing factor between the two is a degree of knowledge: God knows all things, so He sees everything as it truly is.
Contrast#
Saint Augustine makes a point that evil gives contrast to show us the good. For example, when you’re sick and get better, you suddenly appreciate your health, even though you’re just back to the same state of health as before you were sick, and yet you weren’t joyful to be healthy before you were sick.
Think about when you mortally sin, then repent in Reconciliation. You were in a state of grace, then not, then in a state of grace again. It’s not like you gained something greater than you already had. And yet, all of Heaven rejoices.
The existence of immediate evils give contrast and existence to greater ultimate goods:
- Sin exists which gives us free will and obedience (if we couldn’t sin, we’d be puppets).
- Sins such as rape and murder exist which gives us mercy and justice (can you imagine a universe without God’s mercy and justice?).
- Hell exists which ties in with free will, justice, and mercy.
- Poverty exists which gives us charity.
- Christ’s death gives us His resurrection.
All this to say, while we can’t call evil itself good, we can see the necessity of evil existing to bring about greater goods.
A thing of higher quality could not exist unless a same thing of lower quality existed.
Death#
Another example of immediate versus ultimate sense: death.
If you did not know Christ and His promise of eternal life, or an afterlife at all, then you would see death in the immediate sense as final. But if you had the knowledge of the Good News of eternal life, then you would see in an ultimate sense that death is an event early on in your eternal life.
It’s seeing things as they appear versus as they truly are.
Suffering#
Is suffering itself evil?
Jesus, who was fully man, suffered and died, and He could do no evil. Therefore, the act of suffering and dying themselves cannot be evil.
What about the thing causing the suffering? The natural disaster, the disease, the rapist, the murderer, the slanderer?
The persons which cause suffering through their sin are evil in an immediate sense, and a cause for mercy and justice (which are greater goods). But in an ultimate sense, God allows them in His permissive will, as opposed to His perfect will, but it is His will either way, and He cannot will evil. Our universe has not and cannot ever witness an evil so great that a greater good cannot come from it.
But are good and evil then just a math equation, where as long as the good outweighs the evil then evil doesn’t matter?
In an ultimate sense, Good is infinite, because God is infinite, and so good infinitely outweighs evil. But it’s not to say evil doesn’t matter. In an immediate sense, you would never tell someone who just lost their loved one, “don’t worry the evil and suffering will be cancelled out in the end.” You would never let abortion be allowed because “the evil brings about a greater good.”
This is what mortals misunderstand. They say of some temporal suffering, “No future bliss can make up for it,” not knowing that Heaven, once attained, will work backwards and turn even that agony into a glory. And of some sinful pleasures they say “Let me have but this and I’ll take the consequences”: little dreaming how damnation will spread back and back into their past and contaminate the pleasure of the sin. Both processes begin even before death. The good man’s past begins to change so that his forgiven sins and remembered sorrows take on the quality of Heaven: the bad man’s past already conforms to his badness and is filled only with dreariness. And that is why, at the end of all things, when the sun rises here and the twilight turns to blackness down there, the Blessed will say “We have never lived anywhere except in Heaven,” and the Lost, “We were always in Hell.” And both will speak truly.
~The Great Divorce, by C.S. Lewis
As a quick aside, but also somewhat related to the existence of evil, this C.S. Lewis quote got me thinking about the relationship between the Final Judgement and Augustine’s Confessions.
While Augustine was writing his Confessions, he knows that his contemporaries might judge him harshly based on the evil deeds and thoughts he is confessing. But as we read his Confessions today, over 1600 years later, when we know Saint Augustine is in Heaven, we do not read about his evil deeds with a harsh judgemental lens, but almost as if the evil in his life was necessary.
In an immediate sense, if we were alive at the same time as Augustine, we might have condemned him for his sins. In the ultimate sense, we now see those sins brought him closer to God. Can you imagine Saint Augustine without his evil past? Could there even be a Saint Augustine without a sinful past?
This must be a little like how we will see each other during the Final Judgement, when all will be revealed. But since we know who is a saint at that point, we will see the good of the evil in the life of each saint, because we won’t be seeing with the harsh judgemental mirror of Satan, but through clear lens of charity that Christ reveals.
1039 In the presence of Christ, who is Truth itself, the truth of each man’s relationship with God will be laid bare. The Last Judgment will reveal even to its furthest consequences the good each person has done or failed to do during his earthly life
Hell#
What about those in Hell? Aren’t they are evil?
Since they still exist, then God still loves them, so they must be good.
God also allows Satan to exist, and so loves Satan, and so ultimately Satan’s existence brings about a greater good (even if Satan doesn’t want it or know it).
Perhaps we’ll never comprehend the good that God sees in: Satan, all the other demons, those in Hell, and Hell itself. At the very least, we can see that their existence provides the contrast needed for the greater cardinal and theological virtues to exist.
Passion#
Judas betraying Jesus in the immediate sense was evil, and the crucifixion of Jesus was the greatest evil act, but ultimately they led to the greatest good: our Redemption.
The Passion of Jesus also shows the unity in the perfect will of God:
- The Father’s permissive will allowed the death of His Son.
- Jesus’ active will in His participation, starting when He actively stopped Peter from attacking the guards, stopping Peter from committing a greater evil in an attempt to stop a lesser evil.
During the Passion, all of the Holy Trinity must have loved and saw the good in…
- The tree that grew that would eventually be made into the cross.
- The lumberjack who felled that tree.
- The carpenter who shaped the wood into the cross.
- The miner who gathered the iron.
- The blacksmith who shaped the iron into nails.
- The whip that scourged.
- The thorns that crowned.
- The cross used to crucify.
- The Romans who carried out Christ’s Passion.
If at any moment God hated the cross, it would have ceased to exist. Because all of these existed, they were good, and because they kept existing, God must have loved them.
Practical#
Practically speaking, what good is there in believing that all things are ultimately good?
It doesn’t mean getting rid of justice. Just as we still have casinos because luck exists in an immediate sense, so we’ll still need laws because evil exists in an immediate sense. Even in the ultimate sense, God’s judgement, Heaven, and Hell, all still exist, and so our immediate reality reflects that to a much lesser degree.
If you can try to see luck in an ultimate sense, as God sees it, then you’ll see all events, good or bad, are God’s Providence. You’ll have a Christian stoicism like Job during his trials, or Jesus during His Passion.
If you can try to see evil in an ultimate sense, as God sees it, then you’ll see the ultimate good in everything. You’ll see God in everything, and so the good in everything. You’ll forgive the most evil offenses, as God forgives them. You’ll love the most evil people, as God loves them. And like Christ during His Passion, you’ll see the beauty in loving your enemies and loving your cross.