Majestic Monarchy
Thy Kingdom Come
Table of Contents
Greater Good#
Monarchy is the best government.
Specifically, Christian monarchs crowned by the Pope, who at least try to be obedient to Jesus Christ and His Church.
This idea is a mind gate to many in the West today. Which is no surprise, since the Christian monarchs have been destroyed, most of them viciously like the last Russian monarch and the last French monarch. These violent revolutions alone should be sign enough that liberal democracies and liberal republics are a bad replacement for monarchy, but most today are still anti-royalty and anti-aristocracy.
Everyone today was formed by liberal media. Think about all the popular movies and TV shows: the king is always a mad tyrant; the “good guys” are individualistic egalitarian democratic freedom fighters while the “bad guys” are organized authoritarian imperialists (who look really cool).
Everyone today was formed by liberal education that is anti-monarch, anti-hierarchical, and ignores or slanders over a thousand years of prosperous Catholic monarchs (because they were successful in spreading Catholicism).
Why defend monarchy in the 21st century? Because of all the other government systems, it best reflects Heaven, and therefore is the best system for the salvation of souls (see also Church and State, Ill Liberalism, and Americanism).
Europe’s rise is written in the terms of Christianity & Monarchy, Europe’s decay in the terms of Republicanism, Progressivism & Godlessness.
Honour all men. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honour the king.
Thy Kingdom Come#
Every Christian is ultimately a monarchist. Those that think it’s illegitimate to have an unelected authority in this life, will gladly obey the uncreated God in the next. Those that sneer at the thought of a king in this world, will gladly kneel and proclaim “Christ is King!” in the next.
In the Lord’s Prayer we pray to Our Father, thy kingdom come, not thy democracy come. We refer to the Kingdom of God, not the Republic of God.
Christ could have taught us to overthrow our monarchs, instead he taught “Render therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s.”
When Jesus, who had suffered the death of the cross for mankind, had risen, He appeared as the one constituted as Lord, Christ and eternal Priest, and He poured out on His disciples the Spirit promised by the Father. From this source the Church, equipped with the gifts of its Founder and faithfully guarding His precepts of charity, humility and self-sacrifice, receives the mission to proclaim and to spread among all peoples the Kingdom of Christ and of God and to be, on earth, the initial budding forth of that kingdom. While it slowly grows, the Church strains toward the completed Kingdom and, with all its strength, hopes and desires to be united in glory with its King.
Flesh and Blood#
The Bible verses below should not be taken to promote a fatalistic attitude.
Although we should not put our whole trust in princes, that doesn’t mean won’t have some trust in them.
Put not your trust in princes: in the children of men, in whom there is no salvation.
His spirit shall go forth, and he shall return into his earth: in that day all their thoughts shall perish.
Although we aren’t contending against flesh and blood, that doesn’t mean we don’t struggle with flesh and blood.
For our wrestling is not against flesh and blood; but against principalities and power, against the rulers of the world of this darkness, against the spirits of wickedness in the high places.
Ultimately we should always have our full faith and trust in God alone, no matter who wins the Presidency. But it would be good to have some faith and some trust in our human ruler. Who better to trust: a politician only looking out for his donors and how to win his next election; or a monarch trained from birth, watching his elders as living examples, on how to lead a nation for a lifetime?
Integralism and Localism#
Integralism and Distributism (more aptly named Localism) (or Corporatism or Solidarism) pairs well with Monarchism. Monarchy would be the Catholic ideal government, so long as Christianity pervaded every other sphere of government, from politics to law to economics. Essentially any societal idea or system should conform to Church teaching, and these are closer to Church teaching than their alternatives.
A Christian can support Capitalism, but a Christian cannot be a Capitalist alone. He can be a Capitalist Christian, or a Fascist Christian, or a Democratic Christian, or a Monarchist Christian, but at the bedrock, the core, he must be Christian. And this is also why he could never be a Communist Christian, which is an oxymoron, and the evil roots of communism would perish in Christian soil.
Utopia#
No human monarch could ever come close to the divine monarch. But just because we cannot ever be exactly like Christ, doesn’t mean we should not imitate Him and His Kingdom.
It’s true that we’ll never have utopia on this earth. The only utopia is in Heaven. But if an idea isn’t pointed to utopia, pointed to Heaven, then what good is it? Of course, the question is, is the idea pointed to Heaven? For example, communists might think that Communism will bring us closer to Heaven on earth, but this is clearly disordered thinking, as it goes against Scripture and Church teaching. So an idea like monarchy should be challenged in such a way: is this idea or system pointing towards Heaven, does it conform to Scripture and Church teaching, and will it foster the salvation of souls (bringing more people to actual utopia)?
It would be foolish to think “once we have monarchy, then we’ll have total peace.” But Catholic monarchy would result in more peace. And while the Church certainly thrives even in strife, the martyrs being an example, who would want a system that decreases peace and human flourishing? It would be hard to evangelize and catechize when the world is in chaos and everyone is starving.
Ultimately we put our full trust in God alone, who is and has the ultimate authority over all.
Russian bolshevism, replacing eastern Christendom by the grim religiosity of Marx, produced a caricature of the evangelical counsels with many a diabolical aspect. There is a good deal of “communism” in monasteries and convents, yet this is based upon a voluntary renunciation of perfect human rights. On account of our free will we can make supreme sacrifices which ennobles our very existence. Bolshevism on the other hand forces us brutally into a parody of monastic life amidst fellow monks and fellow nuns who hate their habit and sigh under the ferocious tyranny of their pseudo-abbot. This evil distortion of an otherwise Christian ideal is more satanic than wanton, a thoroughly pagan and diabolic opposition to Christian existence. This explains also the reason why the Vatican has found stronger words against “altruistic” bolshevism than against egoistic capitalism.
Royal Saints#
It would be better if the ruling class were saints, or at least trying to be saints.
Think about how many royal saints there are, compared to modern day politician saints. Even though monarchy has more history, there are many more Christians today, and many more politicians (compare a single lifetime monarch versus many short term politicians). If monarchy produces more saintly leaders, it can be assumed it produces more saintly citizens.
Think about how many more Christians exist today than throughout history, and how few saints there are throughout the liberal post-Christendom world. By the numbers alone, monarchy is a system that produces more saints than any other form of government. Of course monarchy isn’t the sole reason for number of saints, but it’s something to think about.
Inversion#
Monarchy follows the natural flow of power: from highest to lowest. Democracy, like all liberal ideas, inverts the natural order. Instead of power flowing top-down from God to kings to subjects, it supposes power should flow bottom-up from the people to politicians. Of course ultimately, even in a liberal democracy, all authority is given by God. And of course the Church allows democracy, and tries to “baptize” liberal democracy into Christian democracy, for example through Church teaching. But today’s nations are evidence enough that republics and democracies are not likely to submit to God and His Church, instead they trend towards becoming more secular and liberal.
I know no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves
~Thomas Jefferson
Family#
The family itself is a monarchy, with father and mother as king and queen, patriarch and matriarch. If it were a democracy, and the parents were outnumbered by their children, would the children make good choices? Or would they vote to eat ice cream for every meal? Does the authority of the father come from the children, as in democracy the power comes from the people?
The children might complain about their parents, but ultimately their parents know what’s good for them and the family as a whole. Teenagers think themselves wiser than their fathers, then grow up thinking themselves clever enough to disobey their kings and popes.
From Rerum Novarum (1891):
Authority of the Father#
A family, no less than a State, is, as We have said, a true society, governed by an authority peculiar to itself, that is to say, by the authority of the father. Provided, therefore, the limits which are prescribed by the very purposes for which it exists be not transgressed, the family has at least equal rights with the State in the choice and pursuit of the things needful to its preservation and its just liberty.
Paternal Authority Must Not Be Absorbed by the State#
Paternal authority can be neither abolished nor absorbed by the State; for it has the same source as human life itself. “The child belongs to the father,” and is, as it were, the continuation of the father’s personality; and speaking strictly, the child takes its place in civil society, not of its own right, but in its quality as member of the family in which it is born. And for the very reason that “the child belongs to the father” it is, as St. Thomas Aquinas says, “before it attains the use of free will, under the power and the charge of its parents.”
Tyrants#
Of course, some kings and queens were and will be tyrants, and lead their people into ruin and even sin. But just like how some husbands and fathers are tyrants, that doesn’t abolish the role of husband and father as head of the family.
Some Christians may be evil, but we do not judge the faith by them, we judge Christianity by the saints it produces: those who best adhere to and exemplify Christianity. So too, when judging any other system, like monarchy, we should judge it by those who live it best. Exceptions prove the rule.
Democracy is a political form, a system of government. It has no social content, although it is frequently misused in that sense. It is wrong to say, “Mr. Green is very democratic; on his trips he sits down for lunch with his chauffeur.” He is, rather, a friend of simple people, and so is appropriately called demophile, not democratic. “Democracy” is a Greek word composed of demos (the people) and krátos (power in a strong, almost brutal sense). The milder form would be arché which implies leadership rather than rule. Hence “monarchy” is the fatherlike rule of a man in the interest of the common good, whereas “monocracy” is a one-man tyranny.
Lawfare#
Why wait until 51% of the nation has agreed that abortion is evil to abolish it? If a thing is evil, why not abolish it immediately? With a Catholic monarchy, it’s possible, but with a modern democracy or republic, whose population is so easily swayed by materialist, anti-Christ, anti-Church propaganda. It’s a miracle that abortion and other evils aren’t mandatory.
But what if the monarch is an evil tyrant who thinks abortion, euthanasia, porn, and war are good? Then in the worst case we have a world that we already live in. But in the average case, the monarch is a Christian who is obedient to God, His Church, and His Pope. This leads to just laws which leads to harmony and unity, fostering true liberty for the people to follow God’s will.
When men speak of despotism or absolute government, they rarely know what they are talking about. No government can do everything. By virtue of a divine law, there is always by the side of every sovereignty some power or other that acts as a check. It may be a law, a custom, conscience, a Pope, or a dagger, but there is always some curb.
~The Generative Principle of Political Constitutions, by Joseph de Maistre
The Last Monarch#
Though all the Catholic monarchs should fall, one still remains as a beacon of hope: the Pope. Like an appendix, seemingly insignificant to the ignorant, but eventually a catalyst to restore the world infected by liberalism, back to Christendom.
In the meantime, today’s Catholics have unfortunately forgotten how to treat a monarch, as so many treat the Vicar of Christ with disrespect. Let’s hope future Catholics, with their Catholic monarchs, will remember the reverence due to a king and his vicar, not to mention the divine King, Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior, and His Vicar the Pope, our Holy Father.
The Church and the family unit could be seen as the last monarchs. The Holy Father and fathers exemplify how rulers should behave, not as tyrants but as servant of servants. Their jurisdiction within their realm is supreme, and they give their life by ruling for life.
C.S. Lewis#
From C.S. Lewis:
“Monarchy can easily be “debunked”, but watch the faces, mark well the accents of the debunkers. These are the men whose taproot in Eden has been cut – whom no rumor of the polyphony, the dance, can reach – men to whom pebbles laid in a row are more beautiful than an arch. Yet even if they desire mere equality they cannot reach it. Where men are forbidden to honor a king they honor millionaires, athletes, or film-stars instead – even famous prostitutes or gangsters. For spiritual nature, like bodily nature, will be served – deny it food and it will gobble poison.
J.R.R. Tolkien#
From The Philosophy of Tolkien, by Peter Kreeft:
The basic argument for tradition is simply that it works. It works in The Lord of the Rings, over and over again. There are many close calls and dangerous turns in the plot, and most of them would not have been negotiated successfully if the protagonists had not known and followed tradition. They remember something their enemies forget.
It is almost always words. Often it is a proverb or riddle or poem. To a culture that scorned tradition, Tolkien offers an epic that exalts linguistic traditions, which were not only his professional specialty, but his love.
There are more than five hundred references in The Lord of the Rings to the past two ages of Middle-earth. Clyde Kilby counts six hundred in The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit together.’ Tolkien’s heroes are humble and therefore look to the past, to the wisdom they had been given. His villains and fools are proud and therefore scorn tradition and look only within themselves for their wisdom.
Tolkien is implicitly asking his readers, his culture, to remember their links with their own ancient wisdoms— pagan, Jewish, and Christian. Few lessons, however indirectly taught, could be more socially relevant than this one, for tradition means linking, unifying over time; and no community can exist without common unity over time as well as place. A generation gap destroys a community more surely than a war.
…
Tolkien’s traditionalism, with all its dependence on the past, does not make the mistake of ignoring the future. In fact, the main reason for tradition is to guide the future. It is not even accurate to say that Tolkien’s heroes balance their traditionalism with a sense of responsibility for the future, as if the two things were opposites. For listening to the past and responsibility for the future are two sides of the same coin.
Tolkien is not a progressivist, but he does not embrace the opposite error either, the notion that “there is nothing new under the sun”, that history is a set of unending and un-changeable cycles of doom. That was the standard pagan philosophy of history as fate. Tolkien’s Christian philosophy of history avoids both the false pessimism of pre-Christian paganism and the false optimism of post-Christian humanism.
G.K. Chesterton#
From What’s Wrong with the World, by G.K. Chesterton:
The Fear of the Past#
Now this same primary panic that I feel in our rush towards patriotic armaments I feel also in our rush towards future visions of society. The modern mind is forced towards the future by a certain sense of fatigue, not unmixed with terror, with which it regards the past. It is propelled towards the coming time; it is, in the exact words of the popular phrase, knocked into the middle of next week. And the goad which drives it on thus eagerly is not an affectation for futurity. Futurity does not exist, because it is still future. Rather it is a fear of the past; a fear not merely of the evil in the past, but of the good in the past also. The brain breaks down under the unbearable virtue of mankind. There have been so many flaming faiths that we cannot hold; so many harsh heroisms that we cannot imitate; so many great efforts of monumental building or of military glory which seem to us at once sublime and pathetic. The future is a refuge from the fierce competition of our forefathers. The older generation, not the younger, is knocking at our door. It is agreeable to escape, as Henley said, into the Street of By-and-Bye, where stands the Hostelry of Never. It is pleasant to play with children, especially unborn children. The future is a blank wall on which every man can write his own name as large as he likes; the past I find already covered with illegible scribbles, such as Plato, Isaiah, Shakespeare, Michael Angelo, Napoleon. I can make the future as narrow as myself; the past is obliged to be as broad and turbulent as humanity. And the upshot of this modern attitude is really this: that men invent new ideals because they dare not attempt old ideals. They look forward with enthusiasm, because they are afraid to look back.
Now in history there is no Revolution that is not a Restoration. Among the many things that leave me doubtful about the modern habit of fixing eyes on the future, none is stronger than this: that all the men in history who have really done anything with the future have had their eyes fixed upon the past. I need not mention the Renaissance, the very word proves my case. The originality of Michael Angelo and Shakespeare began with the digging up of old vases and manuscripts. The mildness of poets absolutely arose out of the mildness of antiquaries. So the great mediaeval revival was a memory of the Roman Empire. So the Reformation looked back to the Bible and Bible times. So the modern Catholic movement has looked back to patristic times. But that modern movement which many would count the most anarchic of all is in this sense the most conservative of all. Never was the past more venerated by men than it was by the French Revolutionists. They invoked the little republics of antiquity with the complete confidence of one who invokes the gods. The Sans-culottes believed (as their name might imply) in a return to simplicity. They believed most piously in a remote past; some might call it a mythical past. For some strange reason man must always thus plant his fruit trees in a graveyard. Man can only find life among the dead. Man is a misshapen monster, with his feet set forward and his face turned back. He can make the future luxuriant and gigantic, so long as he is thinking about the past. When he tries to think about the future itself, his mind diminishes to a pin point with imbecility, which some call Nirvana. To-morrow is the Gorgon; a man must only see it mirrored in the shining shield of yesterday. If he sees it directly he is turned to stone. This has been the fate of all those who have really seen fate and futurity as clear and inevitable. The Calvinists, with their perfect creed of predestination, were turned to stone. The modern sociological scientists (with their excruciating Eugenics) are turned to stone. The only difference is that the Puritans make dignified, and the Eugenists somewhat amusing, statues.
The Unfinished Temple#
The task of modern idealists indeed is made much too easy for them by the fact that they are always taught that if a thing has been defeated it has been disproved. Logically, the case is quite clearly the other way. The lost causes are exactly those which might have saved the world. If a man says that the Young Pretender would have made England happy, it is hard to answer him. If anyone says that the Georges made England happy, I hope we all know what to answer. That which was prevented is always impregnable; and the only perfect King of England was he who was smothered. Exactly be cause Jacobitism failed we cannot call it a failure. Precisely because the Commune collapsed as a rebellion we cannot say that it collapsed as a system. But such outbursts were brief or incidental. Few people realize how many of the largest efforts, the facts that will fill history, were frustrated in their full design and come down to us as gigantic cripples. I have only space to allude to the two largest facts of modern history: the Catholic Church and that modern growth rooted in the French Revolution.
When four knights scattered the blood and brains of St. Thomas of Canterbury, it was not only a sign of anger but of a sort of black admiration. They wished for his blood, but they wished even more for his brains. Such a blow will remain forever unintelligible unless we realise what the brains of St. Thomas were thinking about just before they were distributed over the floor. They were thinking about the great mediaeval conception that the church is the judge of the world. Becket objected to a priest being tried even by the Lord Chief Justice. And his reason was simple: because the Lord Chief Justice was being tried by the priest. The judiciary was itself sub judice. The kings were themselves in the dock. The idea was to create an invisible kingdom, without armies or prisons, but with complete freedom to condemn publicly all the kingdoms of the earth. Whether such a supreme church would have cured society we cannot affirm definitely; because the church never was a supreme church. We only know that in England at any rate the princes conquered the saints. What the world wanted we see before us; and some of us call it a failure. But we cannot call what the church wanted a failure, simply because the church failed. Tracy struck a little too soon. England had not yet made the great Protestant discovery that the king can do no wrong. The king was whipped in the cathedral; a performance which I recommend to those who regret the unpopularity of church-going. But the discovery was made; and Henry VIII scattered Becket’s bones as easily as Tracy had scattered his brains.
Of course, I mean that Catholicism was not tried; plenty of Catholics were tried, and found guilty. My point is that the world did not tire of the church’s ideal, but of its reality. Monasteries were impugned not for the chastity of monks, but for the unchastity of monks. Christianity was unpopular not because of the humility, but of the arrogance of Christians. Certainly, if the church failed it was largely through the churchmen. But at the same time hostile elements had certainly begun to end it long before it could have done its work. In the nature of things it needed a common scheme of life and thought in Europe. Yet the mediaeval system began to be broken to pieces intellectually, long before it showed the slightest hint of falling to pieces morally. The huge early heresies, like the Albigenses, had not the faintest excuse in moral superiority. And it is actually true that the Reformation began to tear Europe apart before the Catholic Church had had time to pull it together. The Prussians, for instance, were not converted to Christianity at all until quite close to the Reformation. The poor creatures hardly had time to become Catholics before they were told to become Protestants. This explains a great deal of their subsequent conduct. But I have only taken this as the first and most evident case of the general truth: that the great ideals of the past failed not by being outlived (which must mean over-lived), but by not being lived enough. Mankind has not passed through the Middle Ages. Rather mankind has retreated from the Middle Ages in reaction and rout. The Christian ideal has not been tried and found wanting. It has been found difficult; and left untried.
…
…The richest nobles before the [French Revolution] were needy middle-class people compared with our Rothschilds and Roseberys. And in the matter of publicity the old French monarchy was infinitely more democratic than any of the monarchies of today. Practically anybody who chose could walk into the palace and see the king playing with his children, or paring his nails. The people possessed the monarch, as the people possess Primrose Hill; that is, they cannot move it, but they can sprawl all over it. The old French monarchy was founded on the excellent principle that a cat may look at a king. But nowadays a cat may not look at a king; unless it is a very tame cat. Even where the press is free for criticism it is only used for adulation. The substantial difference comes to something uncommonly like this: Eighteenth century tyranny meant that you could say “The K__of Br__rd is a profligate.” Twentieth century liberty really means that you are allowed to say “The King of Brentford is a model family man.”
But we have delayed the main argument too long for the parenthetical purpose of showing that the great democratic dream, like the great mediaeval dream, has in a strict and practical sense been a dream unfulfilled. Whatever is the matter with modern England it is not that we have carried out too literally, or achieved with disappointing completeness, either the Catholicism of Becket or the equality of Marat. Now I have taken these two cases merely because they are typical of ten thousand other cases; the world is full of these unfulfilled ideas, these uncompleted temples. History does not consist of completed and crumbling ruins; rather it consists of half-built villas abandoned by a bankrupt-builder. This world is more like an unfinished suburb than a deserted cemetery.
Hilaire Belloc#
From The Crusades: The World’s Debate, by Hilaire Belloc:
Monarchy#
The new Crusading State being of such a kind was continually pressed upon and continually penetrated and raided by the Moslem myriads of the interior on the fringe of which it precariously lay…
Yet for one active lifetime of forty-five years the garrisons remained and were even extended; Edessa was apparently impregnable in the north, so were Antioch, Tripoli, Jerusalem, as one went southward, on to the confines of Egypt. The strange experiment stood firm all that while. Though it could rarely muster an army of twenty thousand men in one field, though it often fought its battles with not a quarter that number, it strongly survived and even seemed permanent.
This miracle was achieved by one main force: Monarchy.
…
This royal office was a further strength to the Christian State in that its Mohammedan enemies possessed no such centre of unity. Monarchy is inherited from Rome. Islam knows nothing of it.
Kingship#
As against the enormous numbers of Islam, the masters of the Crusading State, the French nobility, and the merchants of the seaports—themselves hampered by Mohammedan subjects and functionaries—had one force which Islam has never had: the Roman conception of a State, and with it the Roman inheritance of a continuous single central command; the great legacy of the Empire to us Europeans. It did not suffice.
Michael Warren Davis#
From Why I’m a Monarchist by Michael Warren Davis:
As an American Monarchist, the question that usually appears first in political conversation is, “When did you become a Monarchist?” That’s always struck me as a rather silly question. We’re all born Monarchists. Or, at least, we used to be. Every boy raised by parents who want their sons to become gentlemen will be given the example of Prince Charming. Every little girl should be lucky enough to be Daddy’s Little Princess. Every child wants to live in a castle, sees his father as a king, or her mother as a queen. No little five-year-old dreams of living in an executive mansion or imagines his mother to be a charming and able politician’s wife.
Presumably the egalitarianism of our age will see the decline of children’s monarchial fantasies. Parents who value egalitarianism and tolerance above all else won’t let their offspring delight in tales of the Lion, King of the Forest, or maidens kissing frogs who become princes and live happily ever after—it all stinks of patriarchy and privilege. Nevertheless, these are the tales children not only accept but relish.
So perhaps justifying Monarchism isn’t so much more than justifying imagination. As Christ said, “Truly, I say to you, unless you turn and become like children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven.” (Maybe the Republic of Heaven but… Never mind.) We’re told it’s like unto Godliness to believe in that which this ephemeral world has no time or patience for. We only need to decide what virtues, if any, Monarchism offers that justifies our service in its cause. That will be what any reasonable monarchist will now address. The age of Divine Right is over. Now we must make some sense of that ancient and enchanting order of royalty.
But perhaps you might ask yourself—you who grew up on tales of King Arthur, and Cinderella, and the Chronicles of Narnia—when did you stop being a Monarchist?
Charles A. Coulombe#
Charles A. Coulombe has two great posts about monarchy…
Monarchist FAQ#
The blog post delves into the reasons why Americans might consider monarchism, despite the current republican form of government. Coulombe argues that the foundations of the United States have monarchical elements, which are evident in various aspects of its history, religion, legal system, and more. He suggests that true patriotism involves understanding and honoring this heritage.
He also addresses the question of whether monarchy is inherently evil. He argues that it is not, citing examples of saintly monarchs and biblical figures. He explains the Catholic concept of monarchy, where kings and queens are seen as sacred, anointed by God, and their power is based on the Will of God. The post emphasizes the importance of respecting monarchs as they are considered God’s representatives on earth.
Questions covered:
- Why should an American be a Monarchist? With no reasonable hope for a change in our form of government, isn’t it really just LARPing?
- Is monarchy evil?
- But what about all the corrupt monarchs who ruled in the Middle Ages?
- Isn’t a king simply a dictator with a crown?
- Is the American Republic inherently evil?
- Are republics in general inherently evil?
- Is it better to have a Catholic republic or a Protestant Monarchy?
- What if our King is a tyrant?
- The notion that people can simply inherit power over me bothers me. Isn’t voting an effective tool for checks and balances? Doesn’t it ensure competence?
- Wasn’t serfdom in the Middle Ages a terrible thing?
- Hasn’t the monarchy in England turned out to be a joke?
- How would our rights be guaranteed under a monarchy?
- Who cares what you think? What is the Church’s position on Monarchy?
- What is the Church’s position on Republics?
- I don’t think its the form of government that matters. I think that what matters is what’s in people’s hearts. Are our problems going to go away if our form of government becomes a monarchy?
- How would we decide who our monarch should be?
- Would it be a good idea for America to accept Queen Elizabeth as its Sovereign?
- What’s so holy about the Holy Roman Emperor?
- But wasn’t God angry at the people of Israel for wanting a King? Weren’t Judges better?
- But isn’t Monarchy undemocratic?
Are You a Monarchist?#
You might be a monarchist already without realizing it!
Joseph de Maistre#
From Generative Principle of Political Constitutions, by Joseph de Maistre:
King People#
In physical research, if there is a problem of estimating a variable force, we take the average quantity. In astronomy in particular we always talk of average distance and average time. To judge the merit of a government, the same method should be used.
Any government is a variable force that produces effects as variable as itself, within certain limits. To judge it, it should not be examined at a given moment, but over the whole of its existence. Then to judge the French monarchy properly, a sum of the virtues and vices of all the French kings should be made, and divided by sixty-six: the result is an average king; and the same is true of other monarchies.
Democracy has one brilliant moment, but it is a moment and it must pay dearly for it. The great days of Athens might, I agree, inspire desires in the subject of a monarchy, languishing in such and such a period under an inept or wicked king. Nevertheless, we would be greatly mistaken if we claimed to establish the superiority of democracy over monarchy by comparing moment for moment, because, in this way of judging, we neglect among other things the consideration of duration, which is a necessary element of these sorts of calculation.
In general, all democratic governments are only transitory meteors, whose brilliance excludes duration….
In discussing the different kinds of government, the general happiness is not sufficiently considered, although it should be our sole criterion. We should have the courage to face a glaring truth which would cool our enthusiasm for free constitutions a little; this is that, in every republic over a certain size, what is called liberty is only the total sacrifice of a great number of men for the independence and pride of a small number….
Properly speaking, all governments are monarchies which differ only in whether the monarch is for life or for a term of years, hereditary or elective, individual or corporate; or, if you will (for it is the same idea in other terms), all governments are aristocratic, composed of a greater or smaller number of rulers, from democracy, in which this aristocracy is composed of as many men as the nature of things permits, to monarchy, in which the aristocracy, inevitable under every government, is headed by a single man topping the pyramid and which undoubtedly constitutes the most natural government for man.
But of all monarchies, the hardest, most despotic, and most intolerable is King People. Again history testifies to the great truth that the liberty of the minority is founded only on the slavery of the masses and that republics have never been anything but multimember sovereigns, whose despotism, always harder and more capricious than that of kings, increases in intensity as the number of subjects grows….
Hatred of Authority#
What do all these philosophers want, since nothing that exists or has existed can please them? They do not want any government, since there is no government which does not lay claim to obedience. It is not this or that authority which they detest, but authority itself; they cannot endure any….
It is enough to recall the excellent phrase of Rousseau, who was always right when he spoke against himself: “If I consult philosophers, each has only his own voice.” Deadly enemies of every kind of association, possessed of a repellent and solitary pride, they agree on only one point, the fury of destruction. Since each wishes to replace what displeases him by his own visions which are agreeable to him alone, the result is that all their power is negative and that all their efforts to build are ineffective and ridiculous. Misguided man, learn once for all to recognize these dangerous tricksters; leave them to admire themselves on their own and rally to the national reason which is never mistaken. Remember that every nation has, in its laws and ancient customs, everything it needs to be happy as far as it can be and that by using these ancient laws as the basis for all your reconstruction you can reveal all your perfectibility without giving way to fatal innovations.
Raise your mind again to higher thoughts. The eternal reason has spoken, and its infallible oracles have shown us in pride “the beginning of all evils.” This terrible principle is rampant throughout Europe, since these same philosophers have relieved you of your father’s faith. Hatred of authority is the scourge of our day: there is no remedy for this ill except in the sacred maxims you have been made to forget. Archimedes knew well that, to raise the world, you need a fulcrum outside the world.
To overthrow the moral world, the enemies of all order have hit on this fulcrum. Atheism and immorality stir up revolt and insurrection….
In general, we know almost nothing about the unity of things, and in this we are to be excused, but we cannot be excused for being ignorant that this unity exists. The imaginary world of Descartes represents fairly well the reality of the political world. Every nation is a particular vortex at once impelling and impelled; the whole is nothing but the totality of these vortices, and nations are between themselves just like the individuals who compose them. Each member of these great families we call nations has received a character, faculties, and a mission peculiar to himself. Some are destined to slip in silence along the path of life without their passage being noted. Others herald their progress, and nearly always they are rewarded by fame rather than happiness. Individual talents are infinitely diversified with a divine magnificence, and the most brilliant are not the most useful; but every one has some use, every one is in its place; all play a part in the general organization, all move unswervingly toward the end of the association….
It is the same of nations as of individuals. All have a character and a mission that they fulfill without realizing it. Some are learned and others are conquerors; and again there is an infinite diversity of general characteristics. Among conquering nations, some are purely destructive whilst others seem to destroy only to make room for creations of a new kind….
No nation owes its character to its government, any more than its language. On the contrary, it owes its government to its character, which in fact is always reinforced and perfected subsequently by political institutions. If you see a nation decline, this is not because its government is bad; it is because this government, which is the best for that nation, dies like all human works, or rather it is because the national character is worn out. Then nations must undergo a political rebirth, or perish….
When considering governments in which the powers are divided, it is easy to believe that the sovereign can be judged, because of the activity of each power which acts on the others and, increasing its activity on certain unusual occasions, brings about secondary insurrections which are much less dangerous than insurrections properly speaking, in other words, “popular.” But it is necessary to guard against a fallacy into which it is easy to fall if one looks at only one of the powers. It is necessary to envisage them in their entirety and to ask oneself if the sovereign will resulting from their joint wills can be impeded, thwarted, or punished.
One will find in the first place that every sovereign is despotic and that, with regard to them, only two courses can be taken, obedience or insurrection. It is possible to maintain, as a matter of fact, that although all sovereign wills are equally absolute, they are not equally blind or vicious, and that republican or mixed governments are superior to monarchies precisely because in them the decisions of the sovereign are generally wiser and more enlightened. This is in fact one of the principal ideas which should serve as a basis for the important examination of the superiority of one form of government over the other.
One will find in the second place that it is just the same to be subject to one sovereign as to another.
Monarchy#
It can be said in general that all men are born for monarchy. This form of government is the most ancient and the most universal…. Monarchical government is so natural that, without realizing it, men identify it with sovereignty. They seem tacity to agree that, wherever there is no king, there is no real sovereign….
This is particularly striking in everything that has been said on both sides of the question that formed the subject of the first book of this work. The adversaries of divine origin always hold a grudge against kings and talk only of kings. They do not want to accept that the authority of kings comes from God: but it is not a question of royalty in particular but of sovereignty in general. Yes, all sovereignty derives from God; whatever form it takes, it is not the work of man. It is one, absolute and inviolable of its nature. Why, then, lay the blame on royalty, as though the inconveniences which are relied on to attack this system are not the same in any form of government? Once again, it is because royalty is the natural government and because in common discourse men confuse it with sovereignty by disregarding other governments, just as they neglect the exception when enunciating the general rule….
Man must always be brought back to history, which is the first and indeed the only teacher in politics. Whoever says that man is born for liberty is speaking nonsense. If a being of a superior order undertook the natural history of man, surely he would seek his directions in the history of facts. When he knew what man is and has always been, what he does and has always done, he would write; and doubtless he would reject as foolish the notion that man is not what he should be and that his condition is contrary to the laws of creation. The very expression of this proposition is sufficient to refute it.
History is experimental politics; and just as, in the physical sciences, a hundred books of speculative theories disappear before a single experiment, in the same way in political science no theory can be allowed if it is not the more or less probable corollary of well-attested tacts. If the question is asked, “What is the most natural government to man,” history will reply, It is monarchy.
This government no doubt has its drawbacks, like every other, but all the declamations that fill the books of the day on these kinds of abuses can only rouse pity for their authors. It is pride and not reason which gives rise to them. Once it is rigorously established that nations is best made for the same government, that each nation has that which is best for it, above all that “liberty is not open to every nation, and that the more we ponder on this principle laid down by Montesquie, the more apparent its truth appears,” we can no longer understand what the diatribes against the vices of monarchical government are about. If their aim is to make the unfortunate people who are destined to bear the disadvantages feel them more sharply, it is a most barbaric pastime; if their aim is to urge men to revolt against a government made for them, it is a crime beyond description.
But the subjects of monarchies are by no means reduced to taking refuge from despair in philosophic meditations; they have something better to do, which is to gain full knowledge of the excellence of their government and to learn not to envy others….
Let us go on to examine the principal characteristics of monarchical government…
Monarchy is a centralized aristocracy. At all times and in all places, aristocracy dominates. Whatever form is given to governments, birth and wealth always take the first rank, and nowhere is their rule more harsh than where it is not founded on the law. But in a monarchy the king is the center of this aristocracy: the latter, here as elsewhere, still rules, but it rules in the name of the king, or, if you like, the king is guided by the understanding of the aristocracy….
Avoiding all exaggeration, it is certain that the government of a single man is that in which the vices of the sovereign have the least effect upon the governed.
A very remarkable truth was spoken recently at the opening of the republican Lycée in Paris. “In absolute governments, the faults of the ruler can scarcely ruin everything at the same time, because his single will cannot do everything; but a republican government is obliged to be essentially reasonable and just, because the general will, once it goes astray, carries everything with it.”
This observation is most just: it is far from true that the will of the king does everything in a monarchy. It is supposed to do everything, and that is the great advantage of this government: but, in fact, its utility is almost wholly in centralizing advice and knowledge. Religon, laws, customs, opinion, class, and corporate privileges restrict the sovereign and prevent him from abusing his power; it is striking that kings have even been much more often accused of lacking will than of overexerting it. It is always the king’s council that rules. But the pyramidal aristocracy that administers the state in monarchies has particular characteristics which deserve our attention.
In every country and under every possible government, the great officers always belong to the aristocracy, that is, to nobility and wealth, most often united. In saying that this must be so, Aristotle put forward a political axiom which simple good sense and the experience of the whole of history cannot allow us to doubt. This privilege of aristocracy is really a natural law.
Now, it is one of the greatest advantages of monarchical government that in it the aristocracy loses, as much as the nature of things allows, all those features offensive to the lower classes. It is important to understand the reasons for this.
This kind of aristocracy is legal; it is an integral part of government, everyone knows this, and it does not waken in anyone’s mind the idea of usurpation and injustice. In republics, on the other hand, the distinction between persons exists as much as in monarchies, but it is harder and more offensive because it is not the work of the law and because popular opinion regards it as a continual rebellion against the principle of equality admitted by the constitution….
Once the influence of a hereditary aristocracy becomes inevitable (and the experience of every age leaves no doubt on this point), the best course to deprive this influence of the elements that rub against the pride of the lower classes is to remove all insurmountable barriers between the families within the state and to allow none of them to be humiliated by a distinction that they can never enjoy.
Now this is precisely the case in a monarchy resting on good laws. There is no family that the merit of its head cannot raise from the second to the first rank….
And this order of things appears still more perfect when it is Ty the bired that the aristocracy of birth and office, already softened by the right belonging to every family to enjoy the same distinctions in its turn, is stripped of everything possibly offensive to the lower orders by the universal supremacy of the monarch, before whom no citizen is move powerful than another; the man in the street, who is insignificant against the measures himself against a great lord, measures the lord against the sovereign, and the title of sureet ohich brings both of that under the same power and the same justice is a kind of equality that stills the inevitable pangs of self-esteem…
In the government of several, sovereignty is by no means A UNITY; and although the parts making it up form A UNITY, it is far from the case that they make the same impression on the mind. The human imagination does not grasp a unity that is only a metaphysical abstraction; on the contrary, it delights in separating each element of the general unity, and the subject has less respect for a sovereignty whose separate parts are not sufficiently above him. It follows that, in these kinds of government, sovereignty has not the same intensity or, in consequence, the same moral force….
Let us abandon all prejudice and party spirit, renounce exaggerated ideas and all the theoretical dreams fostered by the French fever, and European good sense will agree on the following propositions:
The king is sovereign; no one can share sovereignty with him, and all powers emanate from him.
His person is inviolable; no one has the right to depose or judge him.
He has not the right to condemn to death, or even impose any corporal punishment. The power that punishes derives from him, and that is sufficient.
If he imposes exile or imprisonment in cases in which reason of state prevents a judicial hearing, he should not be too secretive or act too much without the advice of an enlightened council.
The king cannot judge in civil cases; only the judges, in the name of the sovereign, can pronounce on property and contracts.
Subjects have the right, by means of certain differently composed bodies, councils, or assemblies, to denounce abuses to him and legally to communicate to him their grievances and their very humble remonstrances.
It is in these sacred laws, the more truly constitutional since they are written only in men’s hearts, and more particularly in the paternal relationship between prince and subjects, that can be found the true character of European monarchy.
Whatever the intense and blind pride of the eighteenth century says about it, this is all we need. These elements, combined in different ways, produce all sorts of nuances in monarchical government….
Aristocracy#
Aristocratic government is a monarchy in which the throne is vacant. Sovereignty there is in regency.
The regents who administer sovereignty being hereditary, it is totally separated from the people, and in this, aristocratic government approaches monarchy. It cannot, however, reach it in vigor; but from the point of view of wisdom, it has no equal. It can be said in general that all nonmonarchic governments are aristocratic, for democracy is only elective aristocracy….
Leaving aside the natural aristocracy that results from physical strength and talent, which it is unprofitable to discuss, there are only two sorts of aristocracy, elective and hereditary…. But, since elective monarchy is the weakest and most unstable of governments, and since experience has shown us clearly the superiority of hereditary monarchy, it follows by an indisputable analogy that hereditary aristocracy is preferable to elective….
All in all, hereditary aristocratic government is perhaps the most advantageous to what is called the people. Sovereignty is sufficiently concentrated to inspire respect in them; but, as it has fewer needs and Less splendor, it asks less of them. If sometimes it is timid, this is because it is never imprudent…•
Democracy#
Pure democracy does not exist any more than absolute despotism. “If you use the strict meaning of the term,” says Rousseau admirably, “a true democracy has never existed and will never exist. It is against the natural order for the majority to govern and the minority to be governed.”
The idea of a whole people being sovereign and legislative is so contrary to good sense that the Greek political writers, who should know a little about liberty, never talked about democracy as a legitimate government, at least when they meant to express themselves exactly. Aristotle especially defines democracy as the excess of the republic, just as despotism is the excess of monarchy.
If there is no such thing as a democracy, properly speaking, the same can be said of a perfect despotism, which is equally a hypothetical model. “It is wrong to think that there has ever been a single authority despotic in every respect; there has never been nor will there ever be such a system. The widest power is still bounded by some limits.”
But nothing stops us, in order to clarify our ideas, from considering these two forms of government as two theoretical extremes which every possible government resembles to a greater or lesser degree.
In this strict sense, I believe I can define democracy as an association of men without sovereignty.
“When the whole people,” says Rousseau, “decides for the whole people, it considers only itself…. Then the matter on which a decision is made is general, like the will which makes it; it is this act that I call a LAW.”
What Rousseau calls eminently law is precisely what is incapable of bearing the name….
As a nation, like an individual, cannot possess coercive power over itself, it is clear that, if a democracy in its theoretical purity were to exist, there would be no sovereignty within this state: for it is impossible to understand by this word anything other than a repressive power that acts on the subject and that is external to him. It follows that this word subject, which is a relative term, is alien to republics, because there is no sovereign, properly speaking, in a republic and because there cannot be a subject without a sovereign, just as there cannot be a son without a father.
Even in aristocratic governments, in which sovereignty is much more palpable than in democracies, the word subject is nevertheless avoided, and other, less rigid, terms, which involve no exaggeration, are found.
…
In the second place, justice has not that calm and smooth action that we ordinarily see in monarchies. In democracies, justice is sometimes weak and sometimes impassioned. It is said that, under these governments, no head can resist the sword of the law. This means that, the punishment of an illustrious criminal or accused person being a real joy for the plebs who by this console themselves for the inevitable superiority of the aristocracy, public opinion strongly favors this kind of sentence; but if the criminal is obscure, or in general if the crime wounds neither the pride nor the immediate interests of the majority of individuals, this same opinion resists the action of justice and paralyzes it.
In a monarchy, the aristocracy is only a prolongation of royal authority, and thus partakes to a certain degree in the inviolability of the monarch. This immunity (always very much below that of the sovereign) is graduated so that it is held by fewer persons as it grows in extent.
In a monarchy, immunity, differently graduated, belongs to the minority, in a democracy to the majority. In the first case it shocks the plebs; in the second it pleases them. I believe it to be good in both cases, that is to say, I believe it to be a necessary element in both governments, which comes to the same thing, for what constitutes a government is always good, at least in an absolute sense.
But it is another matter when one government is compared to another. It is then a question of weighing the benefits and inconveniences to humanity of different social systems.
It is from this point of view that I believe monarchy to be superior to democracy in the administration of justice; and I am talking not only of criminal but also of civil justice. The same weakness can be observed in the one as in the other. are magistrate is not sufficiently above the citizen; he has the air of an arbitrator rather than of a judge; and, forced to act cautiously coenwen he speaks in the name of the law, it is obvious that he does not believe in his own power. His strength lies only in the adherence
Bellarmine#
From Saint Robert Bellarmine’s On the Roman Pontiff:
What Might be the best System of Government?#
There can be no doubt that our Savior Jesus Christ could and wished that his Church should govern by that plan and mode that would be the best and most useful. There are three forms of government: monarchy, that is, of one prince, the contrary vice to which is tyranny; aristocracy, that is the rule of the best men, to which is opposed an oligarchy; and democracy, that is, the rule by the whole people, which does not rarely fall into sedition.
The chief philosophers teach this, namely Plato, and Aristotle, and they do so for a good reason. For, if the multitude must be governed, it cannot be done without being governed in some way according to those three modes: either one is put in charge of the commonwealth, or some from many, or everyone altogether. If one, it will be a monarchy, if some from many, it will be an aristocracy; if altogether everyone, then a democracy.
Moreover, although these three might only be simple forms of government, nevertheless, they can be mixed among themselves and from such a mixture four other forms of government are produced. One combined from all three; the second from monarchy and aristocracy; the third from monarchy and democracy: the last from democracy and aristocracy. That being so constituted, the first question arises, what might be the best form of government from those seven?
Now John Calvin, in order to altogether block every way in which one usually arrives by disputation to constitute ecclesiastical monarchy, places aristocracy and democracy before all other forms; an aristocracy from single forms, though in fact it is a mixed form, a government tempered according to his own mind. Most of all, he wished monarchy to be regarded as the worst of all, especially if it were constituted throughout the world or in the Church. His words from the Institutes are these: “Should it be as they would have it, that it is good and also useful that the whole world be comprised by one monarchy, which is still very absurd, but should it be so, still I will never concede that it should flourish in the governance of the Church.” And again: “If in itself those three forms of government are considered which the philosophers posit, I myself can hardly deny either aristocracy, or a form combined with popular government, by far excels every other form of the state.” Thereafter he showed two arguments; one brought out from experience, the second from divine authority: “It was always sanctioned by experience itself, not only because the Lord confirmed it by his authority but even more, in that aristocracy is nearest to the form of government he established among the Israelites.”
We, on the other hand, follow St. Thomas and other Catholic theologians in that, from the three simple forms of government we place monarchy before the rest, although on account of the corruption of human nature we reckon monarchy blended with aristocracy and democracy to be more useful for men in this time than a simple monarchy; provided the first parts should be of monarchy, it should have the second aristocracy, and in the last place should be democracy.
To be sure, in order that the whole matter can more easily be explained and confirmed by arguments, we will take up our teaching on the three propositions. The first proposition: among the simple forms the most excellent is monarchy.
Secondly, blended government including all three forms, on account of the corruption of human nature is more useful than simple monarchy. Thirdly, after we have excluded all other circumstances, simple monarchy simply and absolutely excels.
Simple Monarchy is Superior to Simple Aristocracy and Democracy#
Let us proceed from the first. We do not especially compare monarchy with mixed forms of government, nor do we place it before all mixed and simple forms; but we assert this; if some simple form of government must necessarily be chosen, without a doubt monarchy should be chosen. Now we will prove it by these arguments.
Firstly: all the old Hebrew, Greek, and Latin writers, theologians, philosophers, orators, historians and poets agree with this opinion. First we look to Philo from the Jewish theologians, praising the teaching of Homer: “That for many to command is evil, there should be one king, for rule pertains not to citizens and men more than to the world and God.”
Among the Greeks, blessed Justin teaches that the rule of many is harmful, and on the contrary, the rule of one is more useful and beneficial: “The rule of one is truly freed from wars and dissensions and is usually free.” Also St. Athanasius, “Truly we have said that a multitude of gods is a nullity of gods: so also, necessarily a multitude of princes makes it that there should appear to be no prince: however where there is no prince, there confusion is absolutely born.
Among the Latins, St. Cyprian teaches the same thing, and he proves it most eminently from the very fact that monarchy should be the best and most natural government, because God is one. “For the divine authority, let us borrow from an earthly example: In what way has an alliance of power ever begun with trust, or ended without blood?” St. Jerome says: “One emperor, one judge of the province. When Rome was built, she could not have two brothers as kings at the same time.” Lastly, one can consult St. Thomas.
Now from the philosophers. Plato says: “One dominion has been arranged for good laws, the law of these is best; that governance in which not many command, we ought to esteem as the middle: the administration of many others of the judges, who received no faculty from a senate or the people, and waged wars that they wished and gave men over to be killed. Certainly Gideon, after the victory over the Medianites, killed seventy men in the city of Socoth, and destroyed the tower of Phanuel.
Next, over the fields and those who attended them, the leaders of the Jews were entrusted with a supreme and also royal authority that is so clear that it is not necessary to prove. Therefore, it remains to be seen where Calvin read that the government of the Jews was by the aristocrats and the people, not usually governed by any one particular prince.
By chance, one will object that we have in the first book of Kings (Samuel), Chapter 8, where the Israelites are reproved by God, because they demanded a king. For, if God was not pleased to establish a king for their government, how believable is it that generals and judges were established by God with royal power?
We respond: someone can be put in charge of a state with supreme power in two ways: first, as a king and lord, who depends on no one; the second that for a king or a primary general, someone is indeed in charge of the whole people, but who, nevertheless, is himself subject to a king.
Therefore, God had in this second manner established the government of the Jews in the time of generals and judges that he should, without any doubt, be the proper and particular king of that people, and nevertheless, because they were men, and lacked a visible ruler, and one whom they could go to and appeal, he placed before them some man as for a king, who by no means depended upon the people who were subjected to him, but upon the true king, God alone. Hence, to Samuel: “They have not cast you off, but me, lest I should rule over them.” And with the Apostle: “Moses was faithful in the whole of his house as a slave.”
…
The last reason follows, which is deduced from the enumeration of those properties that everyone holds makes the best government in fact. That first property is order. In the very matter, if it is a better government, it is because it has been more ordered; however monarchy is more ordered than aristocracy, or democracy, thus it can be proved. All order has been placed in it that some man should be in charge, others should be subject: nor indeed is order recognized among equals, but rather among superiors and inferiors. Where there is monarchy, there all things altogether have some order, when there might be no man who is not subjected to someone, excepting he who has care of all things. For this reason there is supreme order in the Catholic Church, where the people are subject to their pastors, pastors to bishops, bishops to metropolitans, metropolitans to primates, primates to the supreme pontiff, the supreme pontiff to God. But where governance is in the hands of aristocrats, indeed the people have their own order when they are subjected to the aristocrats, but the aristocrats have none among themselves. Democracy lacks order in a far greater degree, since all citizens are of the same condition, and they are all judged to be of authority in the commonwealth.
Another property is the acquisition of its proper end. There cannot be any doubt, whether that form of ruling the multitude would be better that more fittingly and easily acquires its proposed end. The end of government, however, is the unity of the citizens among themselves, and peace, which that union appears principally to be centered on that all might think the same, wish the same and follow the same. They will obtain it much more certainly and easily if one must be obeyed, rather than many; for it can scarcely happen that many, of whom one does not depend on the other, might make judgments about matters in the same way. Therefore, when there are many who rule the multitude then one or another commands something or will not suffer someone, or in various pursuits the people necessarily become divided, but this can scarcely happen when it is the duty of only one to command. Use confirms this same thing, and experience is the teacher of things.
Accordingly, in Ancient Rome under the kings dissensions are rarely read amongst the citizens. After the kings were expelled, however, when a magistrate governed the republic for many years, it was a rare year in which the patricians did not contend with the plebeians, and at length they progressed even to civil strife so that in a certain measure that most powerful republic perished at its own hands. It even happened that there was never a greater and longer peace enjoyed in the roman state than under the emperor Augustus, who established the first stable monarchy at Rome.
The third property is strength and power of a state. That governance which in the judgment of all excels the rest, is the one which makes the state more powerful and stronger. It is a stronger state in which there is a greater peace and concord among the citizens, indeed the combined strength dissipated among them is itself stronger; but a greater unity is where all depend upon one, than where they depend upon many, as was proved above; consequently, monarchy makes both a stronger state, and is itself the best government.
Experience agrees: accordingly from the four greatest empires, three rose under kings, obviously the Assyrians, Persians and Greeks: the Roman Empire is the exception, which rose under popular domination, but even then they could not preserve it in great disturbances of affairs without a dictator that is, a king established pro tempore. Afterwards it flourished under Augustus more than it had at any time under the Republic.
The fourth property is stability and long duration. Certainly it cannot be denied that that government is better which is more stable and long lasting, but monarchy - not aristocracy or democracy - endured the longest. But if it is a question of external force, we already showed that without a doubt it is stronger than the rest.
Now it remains to be seen whether monarchy is less given to emergencies and change than any other form of government with there being no external force applied. It is so proved: “Every kingdom divided against itself will be destroyed,” as Christ says in St. Matthew. But it is more difficult for monarchy to be divided than any other form of rule. It is divided less easily because it is more one; but being more one it is itself a simpler oneness than the multitude agreeing as one. Though truly the monarchy, is one in itself, and naturally, nothing other than one, still the multitude agreeing as one is only one from its character, in itself it is many; therefore, monarchy which depends upon one man, can be less easily torn asunder or destroyed than aristocracy or democracy, which depend upon the multitude agreeing as one body.
…Where there are many who rule, it can hardly be the case that there would be no rivalry, ambition and contention present, and in point of fact it does not rarely happen that some impede others, and effect that those who govern the affairs at hand will administer the commonwealth badly. In such a case it is better for them to receive glory in abundance when they exercise the magistracy. But monarchy, which does not have anyone it might envy, or with whom to contend in governance, more easily moderates all things.
Lastly, to the extent that in great households, where many servants are assigned to the same duty, they manage their business badly because one shall leave behind a common duty to another; so even where there are many heads of state, one looks to another and while each one throws back the burden on his colleagues, no one sufficiently employs diligent care to the state. But a king that knows all things depend upon himself alone is compelled to neglect nothing. And also, hitherto, it is indeed proven that simple monarchy is better by far than simple aristocracy. Now let us proceed to prove the next proposition.
Monarchy Mixed with Aristocracy and Democracy Should be More Advantageous in this Life than Simple Monarchy#
The next proposition is such: government tempered from all three forms on account of the corruption of human nature is more advantageous than o simple monarchy. Such a government rightly requires that there should be some supreme prince in the state, who commands all, and is subject to none. Nevertheless, there should be guardians of provinces or cities who are not vicars of the king or annual judges, but true princes, who also obey the command of the supreme prince and meanwhile govern their province, or city, not as someone else’s property, but as their own. Thus, there should be a place in the commonwealth both for a certain royal monarchy and also an aristocracy of the best princes.
What if we were to add to these that neither the supreme king nor the lesser princes would acquire those dignities in hereditary succession, rather the aristocrats would be carried to those dignities from the whole people; then Democracy would have its attributed place in the state. That this is the best, and in this mortal life the most expedient form of rule, we shall prove from two arguments.
First, a government of this sort should have all those goods which, above, we showed are present in monarchy and should be on that account in this life more favorable and useful…
Another argument is added from divine authority. God established a rule of this sort, such as we have just described, in the Church both in the Old and New Testaments. Furthermore, this can be proved from the Old Testament quite easily. The Hebrews always had one, or ten, or a judge, or a king, who commanded the whole multitude and many lesser princes, about which we read in the book of Exodus: “With vigorous men being chosen from all Israel, he established them princes of the people, tribunes and centurions, both captains of fifty, and of ten, who judged the people at all times.” Also, one can see in the first Chapter of the book of Deuteronomy, there is clearly democracy in some manner.
On the Church of the new Testament the same thing will need to be proven, as evidently there is monarchy in the person of the Supreme Pontiff, and also in that of the bishops (who are true princes and shepherds, not merely vicars of the supreme pontiff); there is aristocracy and at length, there is a certain measure of democracy, since there is no man from the whole multitude of Christians who could not be called to the episcopacy, provided he is judged worthy for that office.
Should the Ecclesiastical Government be a Monarchy?#
Since it has been shown that monarchy is the best government, the second question arises: whether the monarchical government is suitable to the Church of Christ. And also that we might separate certainty from doubt, we agree with our adversaries on three things.
That in the Church there is some government, for in Canticles we read: “As an army set in array.” In Acts, we have: “Attend to your own and the whole flock, because the Holy Spirit has placed bishops to rule the Church of God.” In Hebrews: “Obey those placed over you.”
That ecclesiastical government is spiritual and distinct from the political order. When Paul said: “Who presides in solicitude,” and “Who carries out his duties well shall be held in honor twofold,” and similar things, there were not yet any (or certainly very rarely were), secular princes in the Church. Those two things even Calvin teaches.
That the absolute and free king of the whole Church is Christ alone, about whom it is said: “I have been established a king by him over his holy mountain, Zion.” And in Luke we read: “And of his reign there will be no end.” Therefore, an absolute and free monarch is not sought in the Church, or an aristocracy, or democracy, but such a quality can be of ministers and dispensers, since Paul said: “Thus a man esteems us, as ministers of Christ and dispensers of the mysteries of God.”
And our adversaries certainly reckon that the ecclesiastical government which was consigned to men by Christ is by no means monarchy, rather aristocracy and democracy, although they do not all agree among themselves… Following their footsteps, we now bring four propositions into the midst, and defend their strength. The first will be that the government of the Church is not in the power of the people. Second, it is not in the power of secular princes. Third, it is not chiefly in the power of ecclesiastical princes. Fourth, it is especially in the power of one supreme governor and priest of the whole Church.
Why the Ecclesiastical Government Should Particularly be a Monarchy#
The last proposition remains, which affirms that the government of the Church should particularly be a monarchy.
Certainly the first reason whereby the proposition is proved can be deduced from the aforesaid, for if there are three forms of rule, monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy, as has already been shown, the government of the Church ought not be either a democracy, or an aristocracy. Consequently, what else remains but monarchy? Thereafter, if monarchy is the best and most useful government, as we taught above, and is certain that the Church of God was established by the wisest of all rulers, Christ, to govern in the best way, then who can deny that his reign ought to be a monarchy?
Yet Calvin resists this and denies it, because for him, if monarchy were in fact the best form of government, it follows that the Church ought to be governed by some individual man, whereas it is certain that its king and monarch is Christ himself.
But this is easily refuted, for although Christ is the one and proper king and monarch of the Catholic Church, and he rules and moderates invisibly and spiritually, nevertheless, the Church, which is corporeal and visible, needs some single visible supreme Judge, by whom controversies arising on religion might be settled, who would contain all lower prefects in office and unity. Otherwise, not only the supreme Pontiff, but even bishops, pastors, teachers and ministers, all would be redundant: for Christ is the shepherd “and bishop of our souls.” He is the single teacher, whom the Father of heaven bids us to hear. He is the one “who baptizes in the Holy Spirit.”
Therefore, in the same way in which bishops, teachers and the remaining ministers are not redundant, even if Christ does what they do as ministers, so also one who, as a supreme steward, manages the care of the whole Church is not abolished from the midst even though Christ principally manages the same thing.
…
Lastly, others object that if the world ought to be governed by one man in matters which pertain to religion it would be useful that it would be ruled by one in those matters which consider to the political order. But this has never happened nor is it expedient, as Augustine teaches: “With respect to human affairs all realms should be small and rejoice in the peace of small communities. "
I respond: The purpose of political rule and ecclesiastical rule are not the same thing. Accordingly, the world ought not necessarily be one kingdom, hence, it does not necessarily demand one who is in charge of all. The whole Church, nevertheless, is one kingdom, one city, one house, and therefore, ought to be ruled by one. That is the cause of this difference that it is not necessarily required for the preservation of political realms that every province should keep the same laws, and the same rites. They can indeed use laws and institutions for the variety and diversity of places and persons, and for that reason one man is not required to contain all in unity. Yet, it is necessary for the preservation of the Church that all should come together in the same faith, in the same Sacraments, in the same divinely handed down precepts which can not rightly be done unless they are one people, and contained by one in unity.
On the other hand, the question can be taken up whether it might be expedient that all provinces of the world are governed by one supreme king in political matters, although it may not be necessary. Nevertheless, it seems to me altogether expedient, if it could be attained by one without injustice and wars, especially if this supreme monarchy would have under it not vicars and viceroys, but true princes, just as the supreme pontiff has bishops under him.
Nevertheless, since it does not seem that such a monarchy could come into being except by applying great force and many terrible wars, then St. Augustine speaks rightly; maybe human affairs would be happier if there were small kingdoms with happy peaceful communities, than if every sort of king were to contend through lawful and unlawful means to extend and propagate their kingdom. Add to that, what St. Augustine proves is about small kingdoms, but he does not deny that it would be useful if one supreme ruler were over these very small kings; it seems he rather more affirms that when he says small kingdoms ought to be in the happy peace of small communities, just in the same way as there are many houses in a city. Therefore, it is certain that there is one man whom every house obeys, although each would have its own head of house.
Thomas Aquinas#
From De Regno (On Kingship), by Saint Thomas Aquinas:
The absolute merits of monarchy#
[16] Having set forth these preliminary points we must now inquire what is better for a province or a city: whether to be ruled by one man or by many.
[17] This question may be considered first from the viewpoint of the purpose of government. The aim of any ruler should be directed towards securing the welfare of that which he undertakes to rule. The duty of the pilot, for instance, is to preserve his ship amidst the perils of the sea. and to bring it unharmed to the port of safety. Now the welfare and safety of a multitude formed into a society lies in the preservation of its unity, which is called peace. If this is removed, the benefit of social life is lost and, moreover, the multitude in its disagreement becomes a burden to itself. The chief concern of the ruler of a multitude, therefore, is to procure the unity of peace. It is not even legitimate for him to deliberate whether he shall establish peace in the multitude subject to him, just as a physician does not deliberate whether he shall heal the sick man encharged to him, for no one should deliberate about an end which he is obliged to seek, but only about the means to attain that end. Wherefore the Apostle, having commended the unity of the faithful people, says: “Be ye careful to keep the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace.” Thus, the more efficacious a government is in keeping the unity of peace, the more useful it will be. For we call that more useful which leads more directly to the end. Now it is manifest that what is itself one can more efficaciously bring about unity than several—just as the most efficacious cause of heat is that which is by its nature hot. Therefore the rule of one man is more useful than the rule of many.
[18] Furthermore, it is evident that several persons could by no means preserve the stability of the community if they totally disagreed. For union is necessary among them if they are to rule at all: several men, for instance, could not pull a ship in one direction unless joined together in some fashion. Now several are said to be united according as they come closer to being one. So one man rules better than several who come near being one.
[19] Again, whatever is in accord with nature is best, for in all things nature does what is best. Now, every natural governance is governance by one. In the multitude of bodily members there is one which is the principal mover, namely, the heart; and among the powers of the soul one power presides as chief, namely, the reason. Among bees there is one king bee’ and in the whole universe there is One God, Maker and Ruler of all things. And there is a reason for this. Every multitude is derived from unity. Wherefore, if artificial things are an imitation of natural things’ and a work of art is better according as it attains a closer likeness to what is in nature, it follows that it is best for a human multitude to be ruled by one person.
[20] This is also evident from experience. For provinces or cities which are not ruled by one person are torn with dissensions and tossed about without peace, so that the complaint seems to be fulfilled which the Lord uttered through the Prophet [Jer 12:10]: “Many pastors have destroyed my vineyard.” On the other hand, provinces and cities which are ruled under one king enjoy peace, flourish in justice, and delight in prosperity. Hence, the Lord by His prophets promises to His people as a great reward that He will give them one head and that “one Prince will be in the midst of them” [Ez 34:24, Jer 30:21].
The historical merits of monarchy#
[36] When a choice is to be made between two things, from both of which danger impends, surely that one should be chosen from which the lesser evil follows. Now, lesser evil follows from the corruption of a monarchy (which is tyranny) than from the corruption of an aristocracy.
[37] Group government [polyarchy] most frequently breeds dissension. This dissension runs counter to the good of peace which is the principal social good. A tyrant, on the other hand, does not destroy this good, rather he obstructs one or the other individual interest of his subjects—unless, of course, there be an excess of tyranny and the tyrant rages against the whole community. Monarchy is therefore to be preferred to polyarchy, although either form of government might become dangerous.
[38] Further, that from which great dangers may follow more frequently is, it would seem, the more to be avoided. Now, considerable dangers to the multitude follow more frequently from polyarchy than from monarchy. There is a greater chance that, where there are many rulers, one of them will abandon the intention of the common good than that it will be abandoned when there is but one ruler. When any one among several rulers turns aside from the pursuit of the common good, danger of internal strife threatens the group because, when the chiefs quarrel, dissension will follow in the people. When, on the other hand, one man is in command, he more often keeps to governing for the sake of the common good. Should he not do so, it does not immediately follow that he also proceeds to the total oppression of his subjects. This, of course, would be the excess of tyranny and the worst wickedness in government, as has been shown above. The dangers, then, arising from a polyarchy are more to be guarded against than those arising from a monarchy.
[39] Moreover, in point of fact, a polyarchy deviates into tyranny not less but perhaps more frequently than a monarchy. When, on account of there being many rulers, dissensions arise in such a government, it often happens that the power of one preponderates and he then usurps the government of the multitude for himself. This indeed may be clearly seen from history. There has hardly ever been a polyarchy that did not end in tyranny. The best illustration of this fact is the history of the Roman Republic. It was for a long time administered by the magistrates but then animosities, dissensions and civil wars arose and it fell into the power of the most cruel tyrants. In general, if one carefully considers what has happened in the past and what is happening in the present, he will discover that more men have held tyrannical sway in lands previously ruled by many rulers than in those ruled by one.
[40] The strongest objection why monarchy, although it is “the best form of government”, is not agreeable to the people is that, in fact, it may deviate into tyranny. Yet tyranny is wont to occur not less but more frequently on the basis of a polyarchy than on the basis of a monarchy. It follows that it is, in any case, more expedient to live under one king than under the rule of several men.
Mirari Vos#
From Mirari Vos (On Liberalism and Religious Indifferentism) (1832):
All Authority Comes from God#
17. We have learned that certain teachings are being spread among the common people in writings which attack the trust and submission due to princes; the torches of treason are being lit everywhere. Care must be taken lest the people, being deceived, are led away from the straight path. May all recall, according to the admonition of the apostle that “there is no authority except from God; what authority there is has been appointed by God. Therefore he who resists authority resists the ordinances of God; and those who resist bring on themselves condemnation.” Therefore both divine and human laws cry out against those who strive by treason and sedition to drive the people from confidence in their princes and force them from their government.
Diuturnum#
From Diuturnum (On the Origin of Civil Power) (1881):
Society Needs Authority#
11. And, indeed, nature, or rather God who is the Author of nature, wills that man should live in a civil society; and this is clearly shown both by the faculty of language, the greatest medium of intercourse, and by numerous innate desires of the mind, and the many necessary things, and things of great importance, which men isolated cannot procure, but which they can procure when joined and associated with others. But now, a society can neither exist nor be conceived in which there is no one to govern the wills of individuals, in such a way as to make, as it were, one will out of many, and to impel them rightly and orderly to the common good; therefore, God has willed that in a civil society there should be some to rule the multitude. And this also is a powerful argument, that those by whose authority the State is administered must be able so to compel the citizens to obedience that it is clearly a sin in the latter not to obey. But no man has in himself or of himself the power of constraining the free will of others by fetters of authority of this kind. This power resides solely in God, the Creator and Legislator of all things; and it is necessary that those who exercise it should do it as having received it from God. “There is one lawgiver and judge, who is able to destroy and deliver.” And this is clearly seen in every kind of power. That that which resides in priests comes from God is so acknowledged that among all nations they are recognized as, and called, the ministers of God. In like manner, the authority of fathers of families preserves a certain impressed image and form of the authority which is in God, “of whom all paternity in heaven and earth is named.” But in this way different kinds of authority have between them wonderful resemblances, since, whatever there is of government and authority, its origin is derived from one and the same Creator and Lord of the world, who is God.
The Motive of Obedience#
13. And it is impossible that any should be found not only more true but even more advantageous than this opinion. For the authority of the rulers of a State, if it be a certain communication of divine power, will by that very reason immediately acquire a dignity greater than human - not, indeed, that impious and most absurd dignity sometimes desired by heathen emperors when affecting divine honors, but a true and solid one received by a certain divine gift and benefaction. Whence it will behoove citizens to submit themselves and to be obedient to rulers, as to God, not so much through fear of punishment as through respect for their majesty; nor for the sake of pleasing, but through conscience, as doing their duty. And by this means authority will remain far more firmly seated in its place. For the citizens, perceiving the force of this duty, would necessarily avoid dishonesty and contumacy, because they must be persuaded that they who resist State authority resist the divine will; that they who refuse honor to rulers refuse it to God Himself.
The Majesty of Authority#
21. But afterward, when Christian rulers were at the head of States, the Church insisted much more on testifying and preaching how much sanctity was inherent in the authority of rulers. Hence, when people thought of princedom, the image of a certain sacred majesty would present itself to their minds, by which they would be impelled to greater reverence and love of rulers. And on this account she wisely provides that kings should commence their reign with the celebration of solemn rites; which, in the Old Testament, was appointed by divine authority.
The Holy Roman Empire#
22. But from the time when the civil society of men, raised from the ruins of the Roman Empire, gave hope of its future Christian greatness, the Roman Pontiffs, by the institution of the Holy Empire, consecrated the political power in a wonderful manner. Greatly, indeed, was the authority of rulers ennobled; and it is not to be doubted that what was then instituted would always have been a very great gain, both to ecclesiastical and civil society, if princes and peoples had ever looked to the same object as the Church. And, indeed, tranquility and a sufficient prosperity lasted so long as there was a friendly agreement between these two powers. If the people were turbulent, the Church was at once the mediator for peace. Recalling all to their duty, she subdued the more lawless passions partly by kindness and partly by authority. So, if, in ruling, princes erred in their government, she went to them and, putting before them the rights, needs, and lawful wants of their people, urged them to equity, mercy, and kindness. Whence it was often brought about that the dangers of civil wars and popular tumults were stayed.
Obedience to Authority Is Obedience to God#
27. For these reasons, venerable brethren, your work will be most useful and salutary if you employ with us every industry and effort which God has given you in order to avert the dangers and evils of human society. Strive with all possible care to make men understand and show forth in their lives what the Catholic Church teaches on government and the duty of obedience. Let the people be frequently urged by your authority and teaching to fly from the forbidden sects, to abhor all conspiracy, to have nothing to do with sedition, and let them understand that they who for God’s sake obey their rulers render a reasonable service and a generous obedience. And as it is God “who gives safety to kings,” and grants to the people “to rest in the beauty of peace and in the tabernacles of confidence and in wealthy repose,” it is to Him that we must pray, beseeching Him to incline all minds to uprightness and truth, to calm angry passions, to restore the long-wished - for tranquility to the world.
Libertas#
From Libertas (On the Nature of Human Liberty) (1888):
Democratic Form of Government#
44. Again, it is not of itself wrong to prefer a democratic form of government, if only the Catholic doctrine be maintained as to the origin and exercise of power. Of the various forms of government, the Church does not reject any that are fitted to procure the welfare of the subject; she wishes only - and this nature itself requires - that they should be constituted without involving wrong to any one, and especially without violating the rights of the Church.
Notre charge apostolique#
Notre charge apostolique (Our Apostolic Mandate) (1910), a papal letter promulgated by Saint Pope Pius X, condemned Le Sillon and thereby condemned liberal democracy:
Liberty and Equality#
The Sillon has a praise-worthy concern for human dignity, but it understands human dignity in the manner of some philosophers, of whom the Church does not at all feel proud. The first condition of that dignity is liberty, but viewed in the sense that, except in religious matters, each man is autonomous. This is the basis principle from which the Sillon draws further conclusions: today the people are in tutelage under an authority distinct from themselves; they must liberate themselves: political emancipation. They are also dependent upon employers who own the means of production, exploit, oppress and degrade the workers; they must shake off the yoke: economic emancipation. Finally, they are ruled by a caste preponderance in the direction of affairs. The people must break away from this dominion: intellectual emancipation. The leveling-down of differences from this three-fold point of view will bring about equality among men, and such equality is viewed as true human justice. A socio-political set-up resting on these two pillars of Liberty and Equality (to which Fraternity will presently be added), is what they call Democracy.
Government by the People#
However, liberty and equality are, so to speak, no more than a negative side. The distinctive and positive aspect of Democracy is to be found in the largest possible participation of everyone in the government of public affairs. And this, in turn, comprises a three-fold aspect, namely political, economical, and moral.
Authority, Liberty and Obedience#
For the rest, if the people remain the holders of power, what becomes of authority? A shadow, a myth; there is no more law properly so-called, no more obedience. The Sillon acknowledges this: indeed, since it demands that threefold political, economic, and intellectual emancipation in the name of human dignity, the Future City in the formation of which it is engaged will have no masters and no servants. All citizens will be free; all comrades, all kings. A command, a precept would be viewed as an attack upon their freedom; subordination to any form of superiority would be a diminishment of the human person, and obedience a disgrace. Is it in this manner, Venerable Brethren, that the traditional doctrine of the Church represents social relations, even in the most perfect society? Has not every community of people, dependent and unequal by nature, need of an authority to direct their activity towards the common good and to enforce its laws? And if perverse individuals are to be found in a community (and there always are), should not authority be all the stronger as the selfishness of the wicked is more threatening? Further, - unless one greatly deceives oneself in the conception of liberty - can it be said with an atom of reason that authority and liberty are incompatible? Can one teach that obedience is contrary to human dignity and that the ideal would be to replace it by “accepted authority”? Did not St. Paul the Apostle foresee human society in all its possible stages of development when he bade the faithful to be subject to every authority? Does obedience to men as the legitimate representatives of God, that is to say in the final analysis, obedience to God, degrade Man and reduce him to a level unworthy of himself? Is the religious life which is based on obedience, contrary to the ideal of human nature? Were the Saints - the most obedient men, just slaves and degenerates? Finally, can you imagine social conditions in which Jesus Christ, if He returned to earth, would not give an example of obedience and, further, would no longer say: “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s” ?
Justice and Equality#
Teaching such doctrines, and applying them to its internal organization, the Sillon, therefore, sows erroneous and fatal notions on authority, liberty and obedience, among your Catholic youth. The same is true of justice and equality; the Sillon says that it is striving to establish an era of equality which, by that very fact, would be also an era of greater justice. Thus, to the Sillon, every inequality of condition is an injustice, or at least, a diminution of justice? Here we have a principle that conflicts sharply with the nature of things, a principle conducive to jealously, injustice, and subversive to any social order. Thus, Democracy alone will bring about the reign of perfect justice! Is this not an insult to other forms of government which are thereby debased to the level of sterile makeshifts? Besides, the Sillonists once again clash on this point with the teaching of Leo XIII. In the Encyclical on political government which We have already quoted, they could have read this: “Justice being preserved, it is not forbidden to the people to choose for themselves the form of government which best corresponds with their character or with the institutions and customs handed down by their forefathers.”
And the Encyclical alludes to the three well-known forms of government, thus implying that justice is compatible with any of them. And does not the Encyclical on the condition of the working class state clearly that justice can be restored within the existing social set-up - since it indicates the means of doing so? Undoubtedly, Leo XIII did not mean to speak of some form of justice, but of perfect justice. Therefore, when he said that justice could be found in any of the three aforesaid forms of government, he was teaching that in this respect Democracy does not enjoy a special privilege. The Sillonists who maintain the opposite view, either turn a deaf ear to the teaching of the Church or form for themselves an idea of justice and equality which is not Catholic.
A Humanitarian Dream#
We fear that worse is to come: the end result of this developing promiscuousness, the beneficiary of this cosmopolitan social action, can only be a Democracy which will be neither Catholic, nor Protestant, nor Jewish. It will be a religion (for Sillonism, so the leaders have said, is a religion) more universal than the Catholic Church, uniting all men become brothers and comrades at last in the “Kingdom of God”. - “We do not work for the Church, we work for mankind.”
Toward a One-World Church#
And now, overwhelmed with the deepest sadness, We ask Ourselves, Venerable Brethren, what has become of the Catholicism of the Sillon? Alas! this organization which formerly afforded such promising expectations, this limpid and impetuous stream, has been harnessed in its course by the modern enemies of the Church, and is now no more than a miserable affluent of the great movement of apostasy being organized in every country for the establishment of a One-World Church which shall have neither dogmas, nor hierarchy, neither discipline for the mind, nor curb for the passions, and which, under the pretext of freedom and human dignity, would bring back to the world (if such a Church could overcome) the reign of legalized cunning and force, and the oppression of the weak, and of all those who toil and suffer.
The Gospel of the Revolution#
We know only too well the dark workshops in which are elaborated these mischievous doctrines which ought not to seduce clear-thinking minds. The leaders of the Sillon have not been able to guard against these doctrines. The exaltation of their sentiments, the undiscriminating good-will of their hearts, their philosophical mysticism, mixed with a measure of illuminism, have carried them away towards another Gospel which they thought was the true Gospel of Our Savior. To such an extent that they speak of Our Lord Jesus Christ with a familiarity supremely disrespectful, and that - their ideal being akin to that of the Revolution - they fear not to draw between the Gospel and the Revolution blasphemous comparisons for which the excuse cannot be made that they are due to some confused and over-hasty composition.
Distortion of the Gospel#
We wish to draw your attention, Venerable Brethren, to this distortion of the Gospel and to the sacred character of Our Lord Jesus Christ, God and man, prevailing within the Sillon and elsewhere. As soon as the social question is being approached, it is the fashion in some quarters to first put aside the divinity of Jesus Christ, and then to mention only His unlimited clemency, His compassion for all human miseries, and His pressing exhortations to the love of our neighbor and to the brotherhood of men. True, Jesus has loved us with an immense, infinite love, and He came on earth to suffer and die so that, gathered around Him in justice and love, motivated by the same sentiments of mutual charity, all men might live in peace and happiness. But for the realization of this temporal and eternal happiness, He has laid down with supreme authority the condition that we must belong to His Flock, that we must accept His doctrine, that we must practice virtue, and that we must accept the teaching and guidance of Peter and his successors. Further, whilst Jesus was kind to sinners and to those who went astray, He did not respect their false ideas, however sincere they might have appeared. He loved them all, but He instructed them in order to convert them and save them. Whilst He called to Himself in order to comfort them, those who toiled and suffered, it was not to preach to them the jealousy of a chimerical equality. Whilst He lifted up the lowly, it was not to instill in them the sentiment of a dignity independent from, and rebellious against, the duty of obedience. Whilst His heart overflowed with gentleness for the souls of good-will, He could also arm Himself with holy indignation against the profaners of the House of God, against the wretched men who scandalized the little ones, against the authorities who crush the people with the weight of heavy burdens without putting out a hand to lift them. He was as strong as he was gentle. He reproved, threatened, chastised, knowing, and teaching us that fear is the beginning of wisdom, and that it is sometimes proper for a man to cut off an offending limb to save his body. Finally, He did not announce for future society the reign of an ideal happiness from which suffering would be banished; but, by His lessons and by His example, He traced the path of the happiness which is possible on earth and of the perfect happiness in heaven: the royal way of the Cross. These are teachings that it would be wrong to apply only to one’s personal life in order to win eternal salvation; these are eminently social teachings, and they show in Our Lord Jesus Christ something quite different from an inconsistent and impotent humanitarianism.
Be at Once Gentle and Fearless#
As for you, Venerable Brethren, carry on diligently with the work of the Saviour of men by emulating His gentleness and His strength. Minister to every misery; let no sorrow escape your pastoral solicitude; let no lament find you indifferent. But, on the other hand, preach fearlessly their duties to the powerful and to the lowly; it is your function to form the conscience of the people and of the public authorities. The social question will be much nearer a solution when all those concerned, less demanding as regards their respective rights, shall fulfill their duties more exactingly.
A Constructive Catholic Alternative#
Moreover, since in the clash of interests, and especially in the struggle against dishonest forces, the virtue of man, and even his holiness are not always sufficient to guarantee him his daily bread, and since social structures, through their natural interplay, ought to be devised to thwart the efforts of the unscrupulous and enable all men of good will to attain their legitimate share of temporal happiness, We earnestly desire that you should take an active part in the organization of society with this objective in mind. And, to this end, whilst your priests will zealously devote efforts to the sanctification of souls, to the defense of the Church, and also to works of charity in the strict sense, you shall select a few of them, level-headed and of active disposition, holders of Doctors’ degrees in philosophy and theology, thoroughly acquainted with the history of ancient and modern civilizations, and you shall set them to the not-so-lofty but more practical study of the social science so that you may place them at the opportune time at the helm of your works of Catholic action. However, let not these priests be misled, in the maze of current opinions, by the miracles of a false Democracy. Let them not borrow from the Rhetoric of the worst enemies of the Church and of the people, the high-flown phrases, full of promises; which are as high-sounding as unattainable. Let them be convinced that the social question and social science did not arise only yesterday; that the Church and the State, at all times and in happy concert, have raised up fruitful organizations to this end; that the Church, which has never betrayed the happiness of the people by consenting to dubious alliances, does not have to free herself from the past; that all that is needed is to take up again, with the help of the true workers for a social restoration, the organisms which the Revolution shattered, and to adapt them, in the same Christian spirit that inspired them, to the new environment arising from the material development of today’s society. Indeed, the true friends of the people are neither revolutionaries, nor innovators: they are traditionalists.
Catechism of the Catholic Church#
From the Catechism of the Catholic Church:
I. AUTHORITY
1897 “Human society can be neither well-ordered nor prosperous unless it has some people invested with legitimate authority to preserve its institutions and to devote themselves as far as is necessary to work and care for the good of all.”
By “authority” one means the quality by virtue of which persons or institutions make laws and give orders to men and expect obedience from them.
1898 Every human community needs an authority to govern it. The foundation of such authority lies in human nature. It is necessary for the unity of the state. Its role is to ensure as far as possible the common good of the society.
1899 The authority required by the moral order derives from God: “Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God. Therefore he who resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment.”
1900 The duty of obedience requires all to give due honor to authority and to treat those who are charged to exercise it with respect, and, insofar as it is deserved, with gratitude and good-will.
Pope St. Clement of Rome provides the Church’s most ancient prayer for political authorities: “Grant to them, Lord, health, peace, concord, and stability, so that they may exercise without offense the sovereignty that you have given them. Master, heavenly King of the ages, you give glory, honor, and power over the things of earth to the sons of men. Direct, Lord, their counsel, following what is pleasing and acceptable in your sight, so that by exercising with devotion and in peace and gentleness the power that you have given to them, they may find favor with you.”
1901 If authority belongs to the order established by God, “the choice of the political regime and the appointment of rulers are left to the free decision of the citizens.”
The diversity of political regimes is morally acceptable, provided they serve the legitimate good of the communities that adopt them. Regimes whose nature is contrary to the natural law, to the public order, and to the fundamental rights of persons cannot achieve the common good of the nations on which they have been imposed.
1902 Authority does not derive its moral legitimacy from itself. It must not behave in a despotic manner, but must act for the common good as a “moral force based on freedom and a sense of responsibility”:
A human law has the character of law to the extent that it accords with right reason, and thus derives from the eternal law. Insofar as it falls short of right reason it is said to be an unjust law, and thus has not so much the nature of law as of a kind of violence.
1903 Authority is exercised legitimately only when it seeks the common good of the group concerned and if it employs morally licit means to attain it. If rulers were to enact unjust laws or take measures contrary to the moral order, such arrangements would not be binding in conscience. In such a case, “authority breaks down completely and results in shameful abuse.”
1904 “It is preferable that each power be balanced by other powers and by other spheres of responsibility which keep it within proper bounds. This is the principle of the ‘rule of law,’ in which the law is sovereign and not the arbitrary will of men.”
IN BRIEF
1918 “There is no authority except from God, and those authorities that exist have been instituted by God” (Rom 13:1).
1919 Every human community needs an authority in order to endure and develop.
1920 “The political community and public authority are based on human nature and therefore… belong to an order established by God” (GS 74 § 3).