About Church Fathers and Sola Scriptura
Answering Protestant claims that the Church Fathers taught Sola Scriptura
Table of Contents
About Church Fathers and Sola Scriptura#
I’ve studied our faith for the past 5 years and arguments against it from Protestantism and Eastern Orthodoxy. Recently, I was discussing with someone about Sola Scriptura coming from the Protestant “Reformation” and he pulled up quotes from the Church Fathers he had, like Saints Athanasius, Augustine, and Gregory of Nyssa. Athanasius said that the scriptures were mightier than any synod, Gregory said dogmas have to agree with scripture, and Augustine said that he believed only the Holy Scriptures were inerrant. I know they said more that upheld sacred tradition but these quotes appear to hold scripture in higher regard. If there is a further context and understanding of what they meant, I would love to know. This makes me curious. Thank you very much!
Comments#
Here’s what I’ve found.
Church Fathers like Athanasius, Augustine, and Gregory of Nyssa really loved Scripture and said powerful things about it. But they also believed that the Church’s Tradition and teachings are super important. For example, Athanasius defended the Bible against false ideas but relied on Church councils like Nicaea to decide what’s true. Gregory of Nyssa said dogmas must agree with Scripture, but it’s the Church that decides those dogmas, guided by Tradition.
Augustine believed Scripture is without error but also said in On Christian Doctrine that we need the Church to help us understand it correctly. He said, “The Church is the pillar and bulwark of the truth” (1 Timothy 3:15), showing how important the Church is.
Also, Jesus said in Matthew 16:18-19 that He would build His Church and give it authority. That means the Church, guided by the Holy Spirit, is the real teacher of faith.
So, Scripture and Tradition go together. The Bible is God’s Word, but the Church guards and interprets it so we don’t misunderstand.
- Original Poster: This helps a lot, thanks so much!
Let’s read the most current Church teaching on the matter from the Second Vatican Council’s Dei Verbum, 7.
In His gracious goodness, God has seen to it that what He had revealed for the salvation of all nations would abide perpetually in its full integrity and be handed on to all generations. Therefore Christ the Lord in whom the full revelation of the supreme God is brought to completion (see 2 Cor. 1:20; 3:13; 4:6), commissioned the Apostles to preach to all men that Gospel which is the source of all saving truth and moral teaching, and to impart to them heavenly gifts. This Gospel had been promised in former times through the prophets, and Christ Himself had fulfilled it and promulgated it with His lips. This commission was faithfully fulfilled by the Apostles who, by their oral preaching, by example, and by observances handed on what they had received from the lips of Christ, from living with Him, and from what He did, or what they had learned through the prompting of the Holy Spirit. The commission was fulfilled, too, by those Apostles and apostolic men who under the inspiration of the same Holy Spirit committed the message of salvation to writing.
“Sacred Tradition” or “Apostolic Tradition” is defined as being oral teachings, examples, and demonstrations taught either by Jesus – or inspired in the Apostles by the Holy Spirit.
As such, all Apostolic Tradition is fundamentally divine revelation.
So first off, a synod is not divine revelation (save for some stuff from Acts 15’s Council of Jerusalem). And yes, of course a synod must alighn with divine revelation.
We’d need the actual quotes and full contexts of these claims – and they must be studied within the full corpus of the Fathers works, not just taken as a book by itself.
Either way, we don’t claim that local synods are on par with divine revelation meted out orally or through demonstration (i.e. Sacred Tradition) – yes, of course local synods must match up with the Tradition of the Apostles and Sacred Scripture; this person you’re talking with has garbage knowledge of Catholicism and should silence their lips until they’ve read more.
- Original Poster: I was hoping you would comment, you are very helpful in citing church documents and such. Thank you very much!
Lots of articles written about that here
https://www.catholic.com/search?q=Sola%20scriptura&l=en
- Original Poster: Thank you very much!
They weren’t talking about Scripture ALONE they were talking about Scripture as a required corroboration of a tradition.
Keep in mind that Athanasius existed before the Biblical Canon was agreed upon in the councils of Carthage, and Augustine wrote that around the time he played a key role at those conferences.
The church fathers may have also been thinking about the Epistle of Barnabas, or about the Shepherd of Hermas, both of which were popular christian scriptures at the time… and they may not have been thinking about Revelation which was unpopular but added late due to the fight against Arianism.
Heck. The first few years of Christianity called the septuagint the Bible. All we had was the tradition of the apostles.
Scripture exists within tradition and cannot be separated from it. Sola Scriptura is both a misinterpretation of the church father AND an incorrect new doctrine.
- Original Poster: This is great information, thank you so much!
- 100% this! So much of what we hear from modern evangelicals presupposes their 66 book canon dropped from the sky to be passed out at Pentecost. There were at least a couple decades where there were 0 New Testament books written down and then another couple centuries where we had ambiguous definitions of what was and wasn’t scripture.
- Yup. There never was a 66 book Bible until the 1600s. Nobody knows who or when but some publisher just didn’t include the books that Martin Luther had moved to the “Apocrypha” section. They didn’t become popular until the 1800s.
- Its funny, guys like Wes Huff have started taking the line that “it was disputed” which to me would imply a very sizeable camp on each side, but it seems like there is pretty much no one in the other camp for the 1000 some odd years leading up to the reformation
There was literally ONE church father in that camp: St. Jerome. His argument was that he was a translator from Hebrew and he couldn’t find copies of the deuterocanon in Hebrew.
We found most of the deuterocanon in Hebrew in the dead sea scrolls so St. Jerome’s argument was wrong. It’s because the pharisees restricted those books so they survived mostly but not entirely in Greek. 2nd Macabees and Wisdom were originally in Greek. So if we used St. Jerome’s argument we would support 70-book Bibles and not 66 book Bibles.
- Its funny, guys like Wes Huff have started taking the line that “it was disputed” which to me would imply a very sizeable camp on each side, but it seems like there is pretty much no one in the other camp for the 1000 some odd years leading up to the reformation
- Yup. There never was a 66 book Bible until the 1600s. Nobody knows who or when but some publisher just didn’t include the books that Martin Luther had moved to the “Apocrypha” section. They didn’t become popular until the 1800s.
Single sentences taken out of context and presented without understanding? How’s that a valid argumentation?
Athanasius said that the scriptures were mightier than any synod
True, and we should remember it nowadays.
But are they mightier than Tradition, councils, Magisterium or Pope? No, that’s not what he said.
Gregory said dogmas have to agree with scripture
Of course they have to - after all they are established to protect the Scriptures from false interpretations.
Augustine said that he believed only the Holy Scriptures were inerrant
Sure, but this doesn’t deny the infallibility of Pope and Church.
Athanasius said that the Scriptures were more powerful than any synod: the Bible is inspired, and a synod is a meeting of bishops at the local level.
Just because someone expresses this with that phrase doesn’t in any way imply that only the Bible is infallible, eliminating the other two pillars: Tradition and the Church. The Tradition of the Fathers and the Church are also more powerful than a synod.
Gregory said that dogmas must agree with the Scriptures: of course, and with Tradition. No dogma of the Church contradicts the Bible; it isn’t necessarily stated in it that it is something else. Protestants believe many things that aren’t stated in the Bible.
Augustine said he believed only the Holy Scriptures were inerrant: true, from Tradition we take what is common teaching because each of the Church Fathers individually can make honest and unnoticed errors. That in no way implies that the Church and Tradition are not infallible; they are in a different way.
Both are older than the Bible and were used to decide which books were or were not part of the Bible. Without the Church and Tradition, there is no biblical canon.
- Athanasius also said the same thing as well about the church. You know how many people used the bible in the early church to come up with their own heresies. This is why the magisterium is important .
Sola Scriptura has mistrust and pride underlying it.
Mistrust that the oral tradition is real at all.
Pride that by having fstih, humans also become competent in law, philsophy, and understanding God.
The church fathers can be wrong, they are not infallible by themselves. The fathers of the Church as a whole, are infallible since it is part of the tradition; where they all agree, we can believe as inspired.
(Man now we have a protestant claiming some fathers of the Church being infallible but they are always denying the infallibility of the Pope)
Anyway, the Tradition of the Church will never go against the scriptures, you can read the CCC from 101-141. Of course we have it as a highest regard since it is God breath… and inerrant, there’s no contest on that one, we believe that.
The Bible is also treated as Tradition, since the Church defined, though the Holy Spirit, the Canon of Scripture, and the interpretation of it is also Tradition. The synods and dogmas are explanations and beliefs that WILL NEVER contradict scriptures, we find those in the scripture most of the time. Can we believe stuff that is not in the Bible? Yes, but never against it. It is not one against the other, it walks side by side.
- Original Poster: Thanks for this. Just to clarify, he didn’t say these fathers were infallible, he was arguing that they believed sola scriptura.
Hahahaha ok yeah, but they can be in error even if they believe that…
CCC [(CCC 119)]
- Original Poster: lol fair point
- Scripture cannot exist without oral apostolic tradition and vice versa. They go hand in hand. Jesus left us an authoritative church. The Bible clear says that the church is the pillar and bulwark of truth.
- Yep, and if they think the fathers of the Church didn’t believe in the Church, they need to give it another read
- Original Poster: Thanks for this. Just to clarify, he didn’t say these fathers were infallible, he was arguing that they believed sola scriptura.
When somebody throws out quotations, demand they provide citations of where exactly these quotations can be found in the author’s works. Demand it. If they can’t or don’t provide sources, tell them to go pound sand. (And, somebody who quoted somebody who quoted them is not enough: original, primary sources are needed.)
The Fathers believed in baptismal regeneration, infant baptism, apostolic succession, priesthood, the Mass/Divine Liturgy as a sacrifice, and the real presence of Christ in the Holy Eucharist, the intercession of the saints, and prayers for the dead. So, whatever they said about the Sacred Scriptures must be interpreted in the light of all having of those beliefs.
- Original Poster: He did share exactly where they were. I could give you the references if you wish. But yes, they definitely believed all this as well.
- I don’t need them. God bless.
- Original Poster: God Bless. Thanks.
- I don’t need them. God bless.
- Original Poster: He did share exactly where they were. I could give you the references if you wish. But yes, they definitely believed all this as well.
Athanasius said that the scriptures were mightier than any synod
This does not imply Sola Scriptura. Scripture can still be “mightier” than the results of Councils even if the Councils are inerrant. Inerrancy/errancy is not the only metric by which something can be mighty.
Gregory said dogmas have to agree with scripture
This doesn’t imply Sola Scriptura either. New dogmas always need to be agree with previously established dogmas, whether they are found directly in scripture or in councils. The Marian Dogmas need to agree with both scripture and the dogmas from the ecumenical councils. That doesn’t mean that they can’t be inerrant.
Augustine said that he believed only the Holy Scriptures were inerrant
The quotes that I have found from Augustine that state this, it’s clear that he’s talking about comparing the writings from scripture to other non-scriptural writings in from around the time. If you want to take these kinds of statements in a way that implies Sola Scriptura, you also have to accept that Augustine meant that Jesus himself was not inerrant except in what we have that he has said recorded in Scripture. If you want to carve out an “obvious” exception to what he’s talking about, then that just begs the question about what other obvious exceptions Augustine could have had in mind.
Basically, Protestants won’t be able to prove Sola Scriptura by quoting Church Fathers that show a high view of scripture. We have a high view of scripture. To actually prove Church Fathers believed in Sola Scriptura they need quotes that actively deny inerrancy of Church councils.
- Original Poster: Thanks very much!
They cherry pick the church fathers lol. 😆 Oral apostolic tradition and written go hand in hand. One can’t exists without the other. Protestants don’t have valid authority to interpret the word of god. The church fathers did not believe in jusy scriptures alone without the authority of the church. Notice the thousands of splintering sects brcsuse of sola scriptura. They can’t even agree the essentials like baptism and is it necessary for salvation.
Athanasius ‘s four letters to serapion of thmuis , we read this.
Let us note that the very tradition, teaching, and faith of the Catholic Church from the beginning, which the Lord gave, was preached by the apostles, and was preserved by the Fathers. On this was the Church founded; and if anyone departs from this, he neither is nor any longer ought to be called a Christian. Checkmate .
The Main problem with protesants quotations is that they don’t do completely. Let’s see the Fathers you mentioned on the post:
A- Saint Agustine, Letter 54, also called Book I of Replies to Questions of Januarius (400 AD), chapter 1:
<As to those other things which we hold on the authority, not of Scripture, but of tradition, and which are observed throughout the whole world, it may be understood that they are held as approved and instituted either by the apostles themselves, or by plenary Councils, whose authority in the Church is most useful, e.g. the annual commemoration, by special solemnities, of the Lord’s passion, resurrection, and ascension, and of the descent of the Holy Spirit from heaven, and whatever else is in like manner observed by the whole Church wherever it has been established.>
https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1102054.htm
B- Atanasius, Festal letter 2 (330 AD):
<For those who are thus disposed, and fashion themselves according to the Gospel, will be partakers of Christ, and imitators of apostolic conversation, on account of which they shall be deemed worthy of that praise from him, with which he praised the Corinthians, when he said, ‘I praise you that in everything you are mindful of me 1 Corinthians 11:2.’ Afterwards, because there were men who used his words, but chose to hear them as suited their lusts, and dared to pervert them, as the followers of Hymenæus and Alexander, and before them the Sadducees, who as he said, ‘having made shipwreck of faith,’ scoffed at the mystery of the resurrection, he immediately proceeded to say, ‘And as I have delivered to you traditions, hold them fast.’ That means, indeed, that we should think not otherwise than as the teacher has delivered.>
https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/2806002.htm
C- Gregoriy of Nyssa, “Not Three Gods” (371 AD):
< The question is, as I said, very difficult to deal with: yet, if we should be able to find anything that may give support to the uncertainty of our mind, so that it may no longer totter and waver in this monstrous dilemma, it would be well: on the other hand, even if our reasoning be found unequal to the problem, we must keep for ever, firm and unmoved, the tradition which we received by succession from the fathers, and seek from the Lord the reason which is the advocate of our faith: and if this be found by any of those endowed with grace, we must give thanks to Him who bestowed the grace; but if not, we shall none the less, on those points which have been determined, hold our faith unchangeably.>
https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/2905.htm
Bonus track:
It is not convenient for them quoting councils to defend sola scriptura because it was condemned in the council of Nicea 787:
<609 Dz 308 If anyone rejects all ecclesiastical tradition either written or not written . . . let him be anathema.>
Augustine said that he believed only the Holy Scriptures were inerrant.
Augustine didn’t mean inerrancy in the sense that some Protestants mean it. Some Protestant groups, such as the ones that signed on to the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy, believe that the Bible is inerrant on history and science.
Augustine believed that scripture was inerrant on morals, but contained a lot of figurative language, and so scripture wasn’t necessarily a reliable guide to history and science.
This may not be helpful but Sola Scriptura is a modern invention that does not relate to the intellectual and ritual milieu of Christian authors in Late Antiquity.
Those saints are correct in their statement and those statements do not advocate for sola scriptura. They simply highlight the importance of scripture.
The paradox- The writings of Augustine etc. are not scripture… so…