Skip to main content

Protestant Discovers Augustine

A Protestant discovers Saint Augustine’s clear defense of the Catholic Church and the Chair of Peter

| 13 min read | Reddit | Thread

Table of Contents

I’m a Protestant FREAKING OUT over Augustine’s CLEAR, UNAMBIGUOUS support of the Catholic Church SPECIFICALLY headed by the seat of Peter. Why isn’t this cited more?! This feels like a silver bullet for me!#

Before you comment “Catholic Saint is Catholic, in other news water is wet”, hear me out please.

For those who don’t know, Augustine is heralded as a champion of the faith in Protestant circles. Like, there’s Paul, there’s Augustine, and then there’s like Wycliffe way later. Pretty much everyone else in between was in some form or another influenced by unbiblical Roman Catholic Church nonsense, as is commonly implied if not outright stated. But Augustine? He’s our guy!

…So I just stumbled upon these citations from Augustine’s “Against the Fundamental Epistle of Manichaeus”, found here, with the full source being public domain here. Bold is my own.

there are many other things which most justly keep me in her [the Catholic Church]’s bosom. The consent of peoples and nations keeps me in the Church; so does her authority, inaugurated by miracles, nourished by hope, enlarged by love, established by age. The succession of priests keeps me, BEGINNING FROM THE VERY SEAT OF THE APOSTLE PETER, to whom the Lord, after His resurrection, gave it in charge to feed His sheep, down to the present episcopate. And so, lastly, does the name itself of Catholic, which, not without reason, amid so many heresies, the Church has thus retained; so that, though all heretics wish to be called Catholics, yet when a stranger asks where the Catholic Church meets, no heretic will venture to point to his own chapel or house. Such then in number and importance are the precious ties belonging to the Christian name which keep a believer in the Catholic Church, as it is right they should…

We can’t weasel out of this with “oh catholic just means universal, he means the universal body of believers” because he’s clearly referring to a specific organization of believers in Christ led by priests that don’t just come from the apostles, but from “THE VERY SEAT OF THE APOSTLE PETER” himself! WHAT? I knew “catholic just means universal” was wishy-washy but that is a smoking gun in support of the Catholic Church, straight from the mouth of the only Church Father/Saint most Protestants know about!

Therefore I ask, who is this Manichaeus? You will reply, “an apostle of Christ”. I do not believe it. Now you are at a loss what to say or do; for you promised to give knowledge of the truth, but here you are forcing me to believe what I have no knowledge of. Perhaps you will read the gospel to me, and will attempt to find there a testimony to Manichaeus. But should you meet with a person not yet believing the gospel, how would you reply to him where he to say, “I do not believe”? For my part, I should not believe the gospel except as moved by the authority of the Catholic Church. So when those on whose authority I have consented to believe in the gospel tell me not to believe in Manichaeus, how can I but consent?

Take your choice. If you say, “Believe the Catholics”: their advice to me is to put no faith in you; so that, believing them, I am precluded from believing you. If you say, “Do not believe the Catholics”: you cannot fairly use the gospel in bringing me to faith in Manichaeus, for it was at the command of the Catholics that I believed the gospel. Again if you say, “You were right in believing the Catholics when they praised the gospel, but wrong in believing their vituperation of Manichaeus”: do you think me such a fool as to believe or not to believe as you like or dislike, without any reason? It is therefore fairer and safer by far for me, having in one instance put faith in the Catholics, not to go over to you.

These parts in bold are also very relevant. The first one speaks for itself, but as for the second one, I included it because of how similar it is to a common position Protestants hold — including myself, once. “You were right in believing the Catholics when they [declared canon], but wrong in believing [them centuries later]”. As in, the Church once had authority, but lost its way. Such a remarkably similar argument to the one Augustine is refuting here.

I promised my Protestant mother that I would read the best defenses for Protestantism before even thinking about converting, which meant I spent a few hours today reading and trying to understand James White’s defense of Sola Scriptura. He completely dodged the question of canon in The Roman Catholic Controversy (1/10 book by the way, what a regretful purchase. If this is one of Protestantism’s best defenses then I think I’m already Catholic) by citing some haphazard circular argument about Scripture as if it infallibly proved the Councils to be useless, or something? Compare that to Augustine’s blunt statements, as someone who lived in the times of the Councils, that he only believes in the gospels “as moved by the authority of the Catholic Church”, the one “beginning from the very seat of the Apostle Peter”. Again, this is AUGUSTINE, the only early church figure mentioned in most Protestant circles.

I have also just discovered this article by Dave Armstrong, St. Augustine was Catholic, Not Proto-Protestant which utterly destroys my Protestant conception of Augustine. Some highlights:

[I]f you acknowledge the supreme authority of Scripture, you should recognise that authority which from the time of Christ Himself, through the ministry of His apostles, and through a regular succession of bishops in the seats of the apostles, has been preserved to our own day throughout the whole world, with a reputation known to all. (Reply to Faustus the Manichaean, 33:9; NPNF 1, Vol. IV, 345)

[E]ven those good works of ours, which are recompensed with eternal life, belong to the grace of God, . . . the apostle himself, after saying, “By grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God: not of works, lest any man should boast;” saw, of course, the possibility that men would think from this statement that good works are not necessary to those who believe, but that faith alone suffices for them… “Not of works” is spoken of the works which you suppose have their origin in yourself alone; but you have to think of works for which God has moulded (that is, has formed and created) you…. grace is for grace, as if remuneration for righteousness; in order that it may be true, because it is true, that God “shall reward every man according to his works.” (A Treatise on Grace and Free Will; Chapter 20; NPNF 1, Vol. V)

We must except the holy Virgin Mary, concerning whom I wish to raise no question when it touches the subject of sins, out of honour to the Lord; for from Him we know what abundance of grace for overcoming sin in every particular was conferred upon her who had the merit to conceive and bear Him who undoubtedly had no sin. Well, then, if, with this exception of the Virgin, we could only assemble together all the forementioned holy men and women, and ask them whether they lived without sin whilst they were in this life, what can we suppose would be their answer? (A Treatise on Nature and Grace, chapter 42 [XXXVI]; NPNF 1, Vol. V)

[On merit and grace] Someone says to me: “Since we are acted upon, it is not we who act.” I answer, “No, you both act and are acted upon; and if you are acted upon by the good, you act properly. For the spirit of God who moves you, by so moving, is your Helper. The very term helper makes it clear that you yourself are doing something.” (Sermons 156, 11; Jurgens, III, 28)

…the Roman Church, in which the supremacy of an apostolic chair has always flourished. (To Glorius et al, Epistle 43, 7; NPNF 1, Vol. I, 278)

Among these [apostles] it was only Peter who almost everywhere was given privilege of representing the whole Church. It was in the person of the whole Church, which he alone represented, that he was privileged to hear, ‘To you will I give the keys of the kingdom of heaven’ (Mt 16:19)… Quite rightly too did the Lord after his resurrection entrust his sheep to Peter to be fed. It’s not, you see, that he alone among the disciples was fit to feed the Lord’s sheep; but when Christ speaks to one man, unity is being commended to us. And he first speaks to Peter, because Peter is first among the apostles. (Sermon 295:2-4, in John Rotelle, editor, The Works of St. Augustine – Sermons, 11 volumes, Part 3, New Rochelle: New City Press, 1993, 197-199)

…the Apostle Peter, in whom the primacy of the apostles shines with such exceeding grace… who can be ignorant that the primacy of his apostleship is to be preferred to any episcopate whatever?” (On Baptism 2:1,1; NPNF 1, Vol. IV, 425-426)

And thus a man who is resting upon faith, hope, and love, and who keeps a firm hold upon these, does not need the Scriptures except for the purpose of instructing others. Accordingly, many live without copies of the Scriptures, even in solitude, on the strength of these three graces. (On Christian Doctrine, I, 39:43; NPNF 1, Vol. II, 534)

This is really brutally shocking to me. I have read some small doses of Ignatius, Polycarp, and Justin Martyr speaking of things like Real Presence and Transubstantiation in the Eucharist, but seeing such blatantly “Roman Catholic Church” teaching from Augustine of all people blindsided me. What a monumental lie I’ve been fed, that Augustine was some sort of Protestant paragon.

I don’t even know what to do with myself now. The more I research Catholicism the less my Protestant arguments, background, and beliefs make sense. My world is being upended. I’m just… stunned.


Comments#