What convinced you from the church fathers?
Converts share the Church Father passages that convinced them to become Catholic
Table of Contents
What convinced you from the church fathers?#
Before your became Catholic what of the Church fathers did convince you to become Catholic?
Comments#
St Ignatius of Antioch, who died around 130 AD wrote that the Eucharist is indeed the Body of Jesus.
- What source did u read that from. It would be helpful to send to some Protestant friends
His letter to the Smyrneans (I think that’s spelled right?) in AD 107
“Consider how contrary to the mind of God are the heterodox in regard to the grace of God which has come to us. They have no regard for charity, none for the widow, the orphan, the oppressed, none for the man in prison, the hungry or the thirsty. They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they do not admit that the Eucharist is the flesh of our Savior Jesus Christ, the flesh which suffered for our sins and which the Father, in His graciousness, raised from the dead.”
“Letter to the Smyrnaeans”, paragraph 6. circa 80-110 A.D.
- Original Poster: That is actually a strong passage
- I’m considering converting to Catholicism and was shocked to learn that the Eucharist is such a big sticking point for a lot of people. I intellectually accepted that far earlier than most dogmas, some of which I’m still working through.
- The Eucharist and Mary seem to be the big ones Protestants object to.
- Yes, it is very odd when it is so clear from a purely scriptural perspective, as well as early church history view.
- Exactly. And even Luther was a very strong proponent of the real presence.
- funny how i always use this. and i even use iranaeus disciple of polycarp (disciple of John the apostle) and protestant would light up like a robot trying to figure out command not on its program. alot of them sadly thinks that eucharist is a modern thingy and they be shock to see that it can be traced to Jesus to the apostles and to early church fathers.
- Really? Not sure if he was/is a church father, but St Justin Martyr’s apology was issued around 10-30 years before that even.
- Yes really! Scroll down this thread to where I posted what he wrote to the Smyrnaeans (sp?) about the Eucharist.
- What source did u read that from. It would be helpful to send to some Protestant friends
- Tertullian:
“[T]he Lord said to Peter, ‘On this rock I will build my Church, I have given you the keys of the kingdom of heaven [and] whatever you shall have bound or loosed on earth will be bound or loosed in heaven’ [Matt. 16:18–19]. . . Upon you, he says, I will build my Church; and I will give to you the keys, not to the Church” (Modesty 21:9–10 [A.D. 220]).
- St. Cyprian of Carthage:
“The Lord says to Peter: ‘I say to you,’ he says, ‘that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell will not overcome it…’ [Matthew 16:18]. On him [Peter] he builds the Church, and to him he gives the command to feed the sheep [John 21:17], and although he assigns a like power to all the apostles, yet he founded a single chair [cathedra], and he established by his own authority a source and an intrinsic reason for that unity… If someone [today] does not hold fast to this unity of Peter, can he imagine that he still holds the faith? If he [should] desert the chair of Peter upon whom the Church was built, can he still be confident that he is in the Church?” (The Unity of the Catholic Church 4; first edition [A.D. 251])
- St. Irenaeus of Lyon:
It is possible, then, for everyone in every church, who may wish to know the truth, to contemplate the tradition of the apostles which has been made known to us throughout the whole world. And we are in a position to enumerate those who were instituted bishops by the apostles and their successors down to our own times, men who neither knew nor taught anything like what these heretics rave about. (Against Heresies, 3:3:1)
For how should it be if the apostles themselves had not left us writings? Would it not be necessary, [in that case,] to follow the course of the tradition which they handed down to those to whom they did commit the Churches? (Against Heresies, 3:4:1)
But, again, when we refer them to that tradition which originates from the apostles, [and] which is preserved by means of the succession of presbyters in the Churches, they object to tradition, saying that they themselves are wiser not merely than the presbyters, but even than the apostles, because they have discovered the unadulterated truth. (Against Heresies, 3:2:2)
- St. Ignatius of Antioch:
In like manner, let all reverence the deacons as an appointment of Jesus Christ, and the bishops as Jesus Christ, who is the Son of the Father, and the presbyters as the sanhedrim of God, and assembly of the apostles. Apart from these, there is no Church. (Epistle to the Smyrnaeans)
- St. Justin:
And on the day called Sunday, all who live in cities or in the country gather together to one place, and the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, as long as time permits; then, when the reader has ceased, the president verbally instructs, and exhorts to the imitation of these good things. Then we all rise together and pray, and, as we before said, when our prayer is ended, bread and wine and water are brought, and the president in like manner offers prayers and thanksgivings, according to his ability, and the people assent, saying Amen; and there is a distribution to each, and a participation of that over which thanks have been given, and to those who are absent a portion is sent by the deacons. (First Apology)
That portion of St. Ignatius pretty much sold me on Catholicism single handedly
- St. Cyprian hit me hard! I almost got convinced by the eastern schismatics.
- St. Cyprian hit me like a hammer when I was Protestant.
- i know its bad to say. but in a debate with protestants i always use in the end of the debate that these letters are for them. this turn them into tomatoes in seconds lol
- St. Cyprian hit me hard! I almost got convinced by the eastern schismatics.
I don’t understand the Tertullian quote, what was he trying to say?
- Shortly, he’s saying the Church needs the Roman Pontiff. He somehow predicted the argument of the eastern schismatics in the sense that the Church could walk alone without the guidance of the Vicar of the Christ when the Church was built on the very rock of the Papacy and Keys of Heaven were given to the Pope.
- Thank you, i figured it was something like that but it must just be a little over my head haha
- Thank you i figured it was something like that, upon rereading now i can see it
- Shortly, he’s saying the Church needs the Roman Pontiff. He somehow predicted the argument of the eastern schismatics in the sense that the Church could walk alone without the guidance of the Vicar of the Christ when the Church was built on the very rock of the Papacy and Keys of Heaven were given to the Pope.
Thank you for this.
jyk! tertullian isnt a church father
- He is.
- Influential Christians, whether they were clerics or simply theologians, collectively are known as the Church Fathers. So, respectfully, I don’t think its correct to say Tertullian wasn’t one.
Martin Luther can fall into the definition you provided.
Heretics will never be known as a church fathers.
The beauty of all these quotes is, not just are they compelling because of what they say about the subject matter itself, but that they are all dated so early that the Protestant conspiracy theory that Emperor Constantine was responsible for nearly all of Catholicism’s alleged departures from sound doctrine entirely falls apart.
The truth is that Constantine cannot be the source of any of these ideas, and they are not, therefore, 4th century inventions.
St Ignatius of Antioch was a massive help
- Original Poster: Why was that?
Ignatius is John’s disciple. he wrote a letter about Eucharist is the real presence and that there is no other church than the catholic church Jesus established.
it coming from someone close to the apostles of Jesus is pretty big and hard to refute.
- Original Poster: Interesting yes; even Gavind Ortlund said this that Ignatius and the real presence posted a difficulty for him.
- Original Poster: Why was that?
I actually pinned a post series on my profile that dealt with the teaching of the Real Presence from the OT, to the NT, all the way to the sixth or so century. For me, it wasn’t so much just on Church Father that convinced me. It was the consistency of the teaching. One Church Father teaching a doctrine can just be an anomaly; an innovation. But if numerous Church Fathers consistently teach a doctrine century after century? That shows it’s been there since the beginning.
- Original Poster: Could you pin it here?
- Tbh, I’m not sure how. If you click on my name, you should see the very last of the series pinned on “my page”. That last post in the series has links to all the others.
- Original Poster: Could you pin it here?
none, but they made me appreciate church tradition
- Original Poster: Are you a cradle Catholic?
An almost unanimous uniformity on the true presence of Christ in the eucharist.
If you get convinced about that, then there are only a few Christian denominations to choose from.
- Original Poster: How did you tackle those things?
Everything Thomas Aquinas said, and all of the letters between early church fathers that spoke to the origins of the church and early practices.
- Original Poster: Some references?
- The Didache is an interesting read. https://ccel.org/fathers has a good repository.
- Original Poster: Some references?
The Martyrdom of Polycarp. He was so sweet and innocent and the soldiers were so cruel to him, yet he displayed no anger towards them. I’m on mobile and can’t do the story justice, but please read it if you have not
- Original Poster: Could you give kind of introduction
If they’re willing to, have them read “Four Witnesses: The Early Church in Her Own Words” by Rod Bennett. They’ll learn about St. Clement of Rome, St. Ignatius of Antioch, St. Justin Martyr, and St. Irenaeus of Lyons. To read the works of the early Church Fathers is to cease being Protestant.
- Original Poster: Would you still endorse it if you read Fathers knows best?
- If you’re referring to the Jimmy Akin book, I haven’t read it yet. It’s in a huge stack of books that I’m working on. I don’t really see why that book would change my opinion of Four Witnesses though. They can both be good books.
- Original Poster: Not saying to change your opinion; but more in comparison which one you would more likely to give to someone.
- Oh ok that makes sense. I wish I could answer that now for you but I’ve only read the one book so far. I’ll bump Father’s Know Best to the top of the list for the book that I’ll read next!
- Original Poster: I have read the book to largest extend; I have given it to a protestant friend to read since I was leaving the country for good. I was there on internship it was in [country]; I live in [region].
- Oh ok that makes sense. I wish I could answer that now for you but I’ve only read the one book so far. I’ll bump Father’s Know Best to the top of the list for the book that I’ll read next!
- Original Poster: Not saying to change your opinion; but more in comparison which one you would more likely to give to someone.
- If you’re referring to the Jimmy Akin book, I haven’t read it yet. It’s in a huge stack of books that I’m working on. I don’t really see why that book would change my opinion of Four Witnesses though. They can both be good books.
- Original Poster: Would you still endorse it if you read Fathers knows best?
Jesus came for me rebuked me and told me to go home
- Original Poster: How did it happen?
- I was really high and not doing the right thing and in a motel room with my ex at the time. I started reading the Bible and I broke out in tears and couldn’t stop crying and then I felt as if I was not alone it was a heavy burden felt like weight of the world on my shoulders and head I never felt anything like that before I was in shock because I realized at that moment the spiritual world was real and I went outside and I could see shadows flying around the town and they could see me too it was crazy the veil was torn and I knew. And then we talked through my ex who one second was like fuck catholic fuck Mary and then the next second she was gone kinda like quantum leap how Sam becomes another person and the person goes out into the waiting room and it was someone else it was so unreal I couldn’t believe it. he first rebuked me and then told me I am you. And that he wanted bsck in my heart. So I let him in and now he lives in my heart forevermore I almost don’t like talking about it because it was so unreal anyways take care Jesus loves you
- Original Poster: How did it happen?
Eucharist - pretty much an unanimity across the church fathers. Can’t call from memory a father that denied it.
Apostolic succession, ecclesiastical authority and the primacy of Rome - the ones I can safely recommend are St. Ignatius, St. Clement of Rome and St. Irenaeus. The way Irenaeus used apostolic succession to counter the gnostics was just so mind blowing that I had to refrain from reading anything for some time.
Saints, icons and relic veneration - the martyrdom of Polycarp was a very impactful reading regarding that. St. John of Damascus - although a 7th century father - has a solid work defending the icons. To be honest, I think that these are the biggest issues protestants have with the catholic faith. The accusation of idolatry is the number one weapon modern protestantism uses against the Church. IMO this is more of an ecclesiology matter than anything else. When you learn that who dies in Christ is actually more alive than we are, everything else makes much more sense.
- Original Poster: If is easily countered to point to primary sources of the church; it is what men have in their heart.
I converted from protestantism in 2021 and this process required me to let go of anti-Catholic brainwash/sentiments and humble myself before jumping into the teachings. I find that ‘owning’ protestants may not be the most influential approach, however encouraging humility prior to presenting the Catechism of the Church is highly effective. In the end, the argument of authority about St. Peter as the rock of the Catholic Church and tracing the lineage of today’s priests, bishops, and Pope back to him was the turning point for me. Everything else about tradition can be justified via this.
- Original Poster: How did you test the lineage?
The lineage is a result of St. Peter holding the keys to heaven given by Jesus (Matt. 16:14-19). Fr. Mike Smith explains the significance of this passage in depth better than I ever could lol, re-iterating the idea of apostolic succession. Here is the link: https://youtu.be/p4N0hSMCAIU?si=tfDiaDXZL8jYASKv
The ideas mentioned in this video were instrumental to my conversion. I felt the cognitive dissonance about interpreting and sharing the scriptures in my own way as a protestant lift from my shoulders haha. I came to believe that the authority of the pope and the unity of the church in the Body of Christ truly are gifts from God. This directly opposes sola scriptura, which is like the main cause of divisiveness between us and protestants (arguably even more so than Marian doctrine); after accepting the authority of the Catholic Church, naturally the acceptance of the communion of Saints and extra-Biblical tradition came about. To become Catholic is to become a student of history :)
- Original Poster: Interesting what do you mean by extra Biblical?
- This refers to doctrines instituted and ideas held by the Catholic Church that are not directly stated in scripture. Examples include the order of the mass, the liturgical calendar (holidays), the Holy Trinity, the immaculate conception and assumption of our Blessed Mother Mary, the process for canonization for the Saints, the list of books/texts that are inspired by the Holy Spirit and make up the original Bible, and so on. Someone who argues for sola scriptura (which ironically is an extra-Biblical idea) would be inconsistent to practice any of these while excluding others. I hope this helps!
- Original Poster: Interesting what do you mean by extra Biblical?
- Original Poster: How did you test the lineage?
St Augustine. When travel ban was lifted at 2022 (after pandemic) I went to quebec with family and at the giftshop of St Joseph Oratory in Montreal, I picked up the book “St Augustine’s Confessions”, I was thinking at the time: If I find this book I would convert. I found it in a very low shelf of the gift store. It’s amazing experience in the oratory. I read the book all the way in my travel, and after I get back, I registered for RCIA. During RCIA, I read St Augustine’s commentary on psalms (1-37), and next year I was baptised.
I received the gift of faith in the Catholic Church while reading the last few chapters of Justin Martyr’s First Apology. However, I had read many other books before reading Justin Martyr, books which undoubtedly, each in their own way, helped prepare for that moment, including the Apostolic Fathers (Clement of Rome, the Didache, Igantius of Antioch, etc.).
Not too too much. It was moreso just history and logic that sold it to me.
I’m a cradle Catholic and stopped practicing for years. When returning to the Christian faith, I wanted to be as neutral and objective as possible. So I read the Apostolic Fathers with the understanding that God wouldn’t abandon His Church immediately after the last of the Apostles died. If the Apostolic Fathers and the other Ante-Nicene Fathers made claims that lined up with Catholic/Orthodox teachings and at times were at odds with Protestant interpretations, I could give reason to support Apostolic Tradition as opposed to any denomination that came from the Protestant Reformation.
Some things were less controversial than others. Although some Christians continue to observe the Sabbath on Saturdays, the early Church almost at the very beginning honored the Resurrection on Sundays.
The high view of the Sacraments in the early Church, namely the Eucharist, also led me to dismiss low church Protestantism that is very popular in the US. The role of the bishop in a Christian community is also absent in these denominations yet we see it universally through the early Church. I also didn’t see any evidence of female deacons/priests/bishops in the early Church yet most Protestant denominations have women in these ordained offices. Well, either the early Church had it wrong and women are called by God to such roles, but not until the late twentieth century where we coincidentally became more “progressive”, or these Christians have abandoned both the biblical and traditional roots of the Church founded by Christ.
Origen
St Gregory Nyssen
St Abba Isaac the Syrian
St Maximos Confessor
🤗
- Original Poster: Which part of what they said? And also Origen is classified as an Ecclesiastical Writer rather than a Church Father.
- The simple truth is that Origen was an Anaxagorean ex-pagan who paved the way to the doctrine of Nikaea, currently held to be the orthodox one, and the current Trinitarian orthodoxy is simply the product of his thought. —Tzamalikos
- Original Poster: Which part of what they said? And also Origen is classified as an Ecclesiastical Writer rather than a Church Father.
I’m considering it, but the direct link to Peter is pretty high up there.
- Original Poster: You considering what?
- Converting to the Catholic Church, it’s a process that can take months or longer with this local parish.
- Original Poster: You considering what?
The Church fathers didn’t convince me although they were a part of it, the wholeness of the Church did. Everything was coming together, and then Jesus himself came to me. And boom I reverted.
- Original Poster: How long did the process take for decision or reverting?
- Probably 2-2.5 years.
- Original Poster: How long did the process take for decision or reverting?
A book might be of help entitled, “The Later Christian Fathers” starting around 450 AD writings by St Cyril of Jerusalem along with other church Fathers affirming the Eucharist is the Body and Blood of Jesus.
St. Justin Martyr (who was around long before transubstantiation was defined) using the term “transmutation” in reference to the Eucharist.
None, really, I first became convinced I have to become Catholic based on Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited, Lewis’ Mere Christianity, Chesterton’s Orthodoxy and reading various parts from the Catechism.
However, reading St. Augustine’s Confessions, which I did already in RCIA had an enormous impact on me.
- Original Poster: This motivates me to read the confessions of Augustine; I already have the book.
- Oh, definitely do so, theology aside, I found it very, very readable (apart from the last chapter or so, you’ll know when you get there).
- Original Poster: This motivates me to read the confessions of Augustine; I already have the book.
Not confirmed yet, but St. Ireneus of Lyons. When he refuted the Gnostics’ beliefs as heretical (and I have long known they absolutely were, as a Protestant) on the basis of many things including that they denied the Eucharist is the body and blood of Christ, that made me stand up, take notice and say, “wait a minute, I don’t want to fall in that category!”