Paterna Cum Benevolentia
A call to reconciliation within the Church and fidelity to the truth guarded by the Magisterium
Table of Contents
APOSTOLIC EXORTATION
OF HIS HOLINESS
PAOLO PP. VI
We address with affection, with trust and with hope to all of you, confreres in the episcopate, beloved members of the clergy, religious families and the Catholic laity, at the beginning of the celebration of the Holy Year in Rome, at the basilicas of the apostles, after that, in piety and in harmony with feelings and purposes, you have already celebrated the jubilee in the heart of individual local churches.
It is a moment of great importance for the whole world, which looks to the church; but it is mainly for the children of the church itself, who are aware of the richness of his mystery of holiness and grace, which the recent council has appropriately highlighted. And therefore we turn to them for a warm invitation to charity, to mutual union, in the spirit of reconciliation proper to the holy year, in the bond of Christ’s only charity.
In fact, from the moment when we, on May 9, 1973, manifested our deliberation to celebrate the holy year in 1975, we also declared the primary purpose of this spiritual and penitential celebration: the reconciliation that, founded on the conversion to God and on the inner renewal of man, healed the breaks and unrest, from which humanity and the ecclesial community itself suffer today1.
Then, by our decision, the jubilee celebration began in particular churches since the Pentecost of 1973, we have not left out any opportunity to accompany its development with our doctrinal and pastoral interventions and with pressing references to this purpose, believing it in perfect coherence with the most authentic spirit of the gospel and with the lines of renewal traced by Vatican II to the whole church. This, instituted by Christ as a permanent attestation of the reconciliation he accomplished in fulfillment of the Father’s will2, has the task of “making God the Father and his incarnate Son present and almost visible, renewing himself and purifying himself without ceasing under the guidance of the Holy Spirit”3. It seemed, therefore, necessary for us, for that task to be given ever better satisfaction, to accentuate the urgency that everyone in the church promote the “unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace” (Eph 4.3).
Therefore, in the run-up to the solemnity of the Lord’s birth - given by us for the opening of the universal jubilee in Rome -4, we address our exhortation to the pastors and faithful of the church, so that all may become actors and promoters of reconciliation with God and with our brothers and sisters, and next Christmas of the Holy Year is truly, for the world, the “Christmas of peace”5 as was that of the Savior.
I. The Church, Reconciled and Reconciling World#
From the beginning, the church became aware of the transformation carried out by the redemptive work of Christ, and gave it the very happy announcement: that, for it, the world has become a radically new reality (cf. 2 Cor 5,17), in which men found God and hope (cf. Eph 2,12) and, as of now, are made partakers of the glory of God “through our lord Jesus Christ, from whom we have now obtained reconciliation” (Rm 5.11). This novelty is due exclusively to the merciful initiative of God (cf. 2 Cor 5.18 to 20; Col 1,20-22), she comes to meet the man who, having moved away from him because of his own fault, could no longer find peace with his Creator.
Then that initiative of God was actualized through a directly divine intervention. In fact, he did not simply forgive us, nor did he use a simple intermediary man between us and him; but he constituted his “only begotten Son as intercessor of peace”6: “he who had not known sin, God treated him as sin in our favor, so that we could become God’s righteousness through him” (2 Cor 5.21). In reality Christ, dying for us, canceled “the written document of our debt, the conditions of which were unfavorable to us. He took him out of the way by nailing him to the cross “(Col 2.14); and, by means of the cross. he reconciled us with God, “destroying enmity in himself” (Eph 2.16). The reconciliation, carried out by God in Christ crucified, is part of the history of the world, which now includes among its irreversible components the event of God made man and died to save him. But it finds permanent historical expression in the body of Christ, which is the church, in which the Son of God summons “his brothers from all peoples”7, and, as its head (cf. Col 1.18), it is the principle of authority and action that constitutes it on earth as a “reconciled world”8.
Since the church is the body of Christ and Christ is “the savior of his body” (Eph 5.23), all, to be members worthy of this body, must, in fidelity to the Christian commitment, contribute to maintaining it in its original nature as a community of reconciled, deriving from Christ our peace (cf. Eph 2.14) which “makes us pacified”9. Reconciliation, in fact, once received, is, like grace and like life, an impulse and a current that transforms its beneficiaries into operators and transmitters of the same. For every Christian, this is the credential of its authenticity in the church and in the world: “Peace begins with you, so that, when you are peaceful, you can bring peace to others”10. The duty of pacification personally draws on all and individuals of the faithful; and, without its fulfillment, even the cultural sacrifice they intended to make remains ineffective (cf. Mt 5.23). Mutual reconciliation participates, in fact, in the same value as the sacrifice itself, and with this it together constitutes a single offer to God pleasing11. So that, then, this duty is effectively fulfilled, and the reconciliation, which takes place in the depths of the heart, also has a public character such as the death of Christ who procures it, the Lord, conferred on the apostles and pastors of the church, their successors, the “ministry of reconciliation” (2 Cor 5.18). They therefore “assuming almost the person of Christ”12, are permanently appointed to “build their flock in truth and holiness”13.
The church, therefore, because it is a “reconciled world”, is also a natively and permanently reconciling reality; and as such it is the presence and action of God “that reconciles the world to itself in Christ “(2 Cor 5.19), which are expressed primarily in baptism, in the forgiveness of sins and in the Eucharistic celebration, actualization of the redemptive sacrifice of Christ and an effective sign of the unity of the people of God14.
II. The Church, Sacrament of Unity#
Reconciliation, in its double aspect of recovered peace between God and men and men among them, is the first fruit of redemption; and has, like this one, universal dimensions both in extension and in intensity. In it, therefore, all creation is involved “until the time of the restoration of all things” (At 3,21), when all creatures meet again with Christ, the firstborn of the resurrected dead (cf. Col 1.18). And since said reconciliation finds privileged expression and more dense concentration in the church, this is “as a sacrament or sign and instrument of intimate union with God and of the unity of all mankind”15; that is, the place of irradiation of union of men with God and of unity among them, which, through progressive affirmation over time, will find fulfillment in the consummation of the times.
In order to fully express this sacramentality, to which its very raison d’etre is linked, the church, as required for each sacrament, must be a significant sign; that it realizes and verifies, that is, that concord and convergence of doctrine, life and worship, which characterized its first days (cf. At 2,42), and which remain forever its essential element (cf. Eph 4.4-6; Cor 1 16). This concord - unlike any division that pays attention to the compactness of its structure - can only increase the strength of its testimony, reveals the reasons for its existence, and illuminates its credibility more.
Therefore, to cooperate in God’s plans in the world, all the faithful must persevere in fidelity to the Holy Spirit, who unifies the church “in communion and ministry” and “with the power of the gospel he rejuvenates the church, and continually renews it and leads it to perfect union with his husband”16.
This fidelity cannot fail to have happy ecumenical repercussions on the search for the visible unity of all Christians, in the manner established by Christ, in one and the same church; which will thus be the most effective ferment of fraternal cohesion in the community of peoples.
III. Obscurations of the Church’s Sacramentality#
Nonetheless, “although the church by virtue of the Holy Spirit has always remained the faithful bride of its Lord, and has never ceased to be a sign of salvation in the world, however, it does not at all ignore that among its members, both clerics and lay people, in the long series of past centuries, did not miss those who were not faithful to the Spirit of God”17. In reality “in this one and united church of God, some splits arose from the earliest times, condemned with serious words by the apostle”18. When, then, the known fractures not known to stem occurred, the church overcame the situation of inner dissent, clearly reaffirming, as an irreplaceable condition of communion, those principles that made it possible to keep its constitutive unity intact, and made it possible to manifest it “in the confession of a single faith, in the common celebration of divine worship and in the fraternal harmony of the family of God”19.
But the ferments of infidelity to the Holy Spirit that are found in the church in our day appear equally dangerous, such as to require this clarification and this invitation to unity, and unfortunately try to undermine it from the inside. The promoters and victims of this process, in reality few in comparison with the immense majority of the faithful, they claim to remain in the church with the same rights and the same possibilities of expression and action as others to attack ecclesial unity; and not wanting to recognize in the church a single reality resulting from a double human and divine element, analogous to the mystery of the incarnate Word, which constitutes it “on the earth community of faith, of hope and charity as a visible organism “, through which Christ” spreads truth and grace over all”20, they oppose the hierarchy, as if every act of opposition is a constitutive moment of the truth about the church to be rediscovered which Christ would have established it; question the duty of obedience to the authority desired by the Redeemer; they put church pastors on charges not so much for what they do or how they do it, but simply because, as they say, they would be the custodians of an ecclesiastical system or apparatus shared with the institution of Christ; in this way they cause bewilderment in the whole community, introducing into it the fruit of dialectical theories extraneous to the Spirit of Christ. By using the words of the gospel, they alter its meaning. We observe this state of affairs with pain, even if, as we have said, it is very small in comparison with the great mass of faithful Christians;but we cannot fail to arise with the same vigor as s. Paul against this lack of loyalty and justice. We appeal to all Christians of good will not be impressed or disoriented by the undue pressure of unfortunately misguided brothers, and who are always present at our prayer and close to our hearts.
As for us, we reaffirm that the only church of Christ, “in this world constituted and organized as a society, exists in the Catholic Church, governed by Peter’s successor and by the bishops in communion with him, even though there are several elements of sanctification and truth outside his body”21, we also reaffirm that these pastors of the church, who preside over the people of God in his name, with the humility of the servants, but also with the frankness of the apostles (cf. At 4.31) to which they succeed, have the right and duty to proclaim: “Until … we sit here, until we preside, we have authority and strength, even if we are unworthy of it”22.
IV. Areas Where the Church’s Sacramentality Is Obscured#
The process we have described takes the form of a doctrinal dissent, which wants to be sponsored by theological pluralism and is pushed, not infrequently, to dogmatic relativism, reducer, in different ways, of the integrity of faith. And even when it is not pushed to dogmatic relativism, said pluralism is sometimes considered legitimate theological place, such as to allow positions against the authentic magisterium of the Roman pontiff himself and of the episcopal hierarchy, the only authoritative interpreters of the divine revelation contained in the s. tradition and in the S. Writing23.
We recognize the pluralism of research and thought that variously explores and exposes dogma, but without eliminating the identical objective meaning, legitimate right of citizenship in the church, as a natural component of its catholicity, as well as a sign of cultural wealth and personal commitment of those who belong to it. We also recognize the invaluable values entered by it in the field of Christian spirituality, ecclesial and religious institutions, as well as in the field of liturgical expressions and disciplinary norms: values that flow into that “variety that acts together “which” shows more clearly the catholicity of the undivided church”24.
Indeed, we admit that a balanced theological pluralism is founded in the same mystery of Christ, whose inscrutable riches (cf. Eph 3.8) transcend the expressive capacities of all eras and cultures. The doctrine of faith, therefore, which necessarily derives from that mystery - since, in order to salvation, “there is no other mystery of God, if not Christ”25 - always calls for new explorations. In reality, the prospects of the word of God are many and there are many perspectives of the faithful who explore them26 that convergence in the same faith is never immune from personal peculiarities in the adhesion of each. However, different emphases in understanding the same faith do not affect its essential contents, because they are unified in the common adhesion to the magisterium of the church; which, while it is, as a near norm, determinant of the faith of all, all also guarantees from the subjective judgment of any differentiated interpretation of the same.
But what about that pluralism that considers faith and its enunciation not as a community heritage, therefore ecclesial, but as an individual finding of free criticism and free examination of the word of God? In fact, without the mediation of the magisterium of the church, to which the apostles entrusted their own magisterium27, and which therefore teaches “only what has been transmitted”28, the sure conjunction with Christ through the apostles remains compromised, who are the “transmitters of what they themselves had received”29. And therefore, once perseverance in the doctrine transmitted by the apostles has been compromised, it happens that, perhaps wanting to evade the difficulties of the mystery, formulas of illusory comprehensibility are sought which dissolve its real content; and thus, doctrines are built that are not adhering to the objectivity of the faith or even contrary to it and, moreover, crystallized in the coexistence of opposing conceptions also among them.
Furthermore, it should not be hidden that any yielding in the identity of faith also matters decay in mutual love. Those, in fact, who have lost the joy that derives from faith (cf. Fil 1,25), are driven to beg glory from one another and not to seek what comes only from God (cf. Gv 5.44), to the detriment of fraternal communion. To the sense of the church, which makes everyone recognize the same dignity and freedom as the children of God30, the partisan spirit that leads to discriminating choices cannot be replaced, thus depriving charity even in its natural support, which is justice. It would be a vain intent to transform ecclesial communion for the better according to the type shared at group level.
Shouldn’t we all perfect ourselves through the gospel? And where does this fully manifest its divinely congenital virtue, if not in the church, with the contribution of all believers without distinction?
Finally, this partisan spirit is also reflected negatively in the necessary convergence of worship and prayer, and translates into an isolation dictated by a spirit of presumption, certainly not evangelical, which precludes justification before God (cf. Lc 18.10 to 14).
We, as far as we can, want to understand the root of this situation, and compare it to the analogous situation in which today’s civil society lives, divided into groups opposite each other. Unfortunately, even the church seems to suffer a little ’ the backlash of such a condition: yet it must not assimilate what is rather a pathological state. The church must preserve its originality as a unified family in the diversity of its members; on the contrary, it must be the leaven that helps society to react, as was said of the first Christians: “See how much they love each other!”31. It is with this picture of the first community before your eyes - certainly not an idyllic picture, but matured through trial and suffering - which we ask everyone to overcome the illegitimate and dangerous differences to recognize themselves as brothers that the love of Christ unites.
V. Polarization of Dissent#
The internal oppositions interesting the various sectors of ecclesial life, if they stabilize in a state of dissidence, lead to contrast a plurality of “institutions or communities of dissent “, which are not according to the nature of the church, which with the creation of opposite hamlets and factions, fixed on irreconcilable positions, would lose its own constitutional fabric. Then there is the polarization of dissent by virtue of which all interest is concentrated on the respective groups, practically autocephalous, each of which believes to honor God. This situation carries within itself and introduces as far as it can, in ecclesial communion, the germs of disintegration.
We sincerely hope that the voice of consciousness will induce individuals to a process of reflection that will lead them to a more conscious choice. We to this, each and every one, urge: “Unleash the intimate secret of your heart and penetrate, as a diligent explorer, into the maze of your soul”32. And in each one we would like to awaken the nostalgia for what he has lost: “Remember therefore where you fell from, repent and do the first works” (cf. Ap 2.5). And we would like to urge each one to reconsider the divine prodigy that has been accomplished in him and to feel his conditioning needs before the Lord: “The Christian must be afraid of nothing other than being separated from the body of Christ. If, in fact, he is separated from the body of Christ, he is not his member; if it is not its member, it is not nourished by its Spirit. And if someone - says the apostle - does not have the Spirit of Christ, it does not belong to him”33.
VI. Ethics and Dynamics of Reconciliation#
It is therefore a vital necessity that everyone in the church, bishops, priests, religious, lay people, take an active part in a common effort of full reconciliation, so that peace “nourist of love and parent of unity” may be recomposed in all and among all”34, Therefore, let each one manifest himself ever more docile disciple of the Lord, who makes reconciliation between us the condition for being forgiven by the Father (cf. Mc 11,26), and of mutual charity the condition for being recognized as his disciples (cf. Gv 13.35). Anyone, therefore, feels in any way involved in this state of division, returns to listen to his voice which urges him irresistible even when he is about to pray: “Go ’ first to reconcile with your brother “(Mt 5.24).
All at the same time, in different measures and forms according to the position and state of each, reconsidering the saving work of God towards us, are committed to creating the right climate for reconciliation to become effective. Since we have been reconciled with him on the exclusive initiative of his love, let our behavior be based on benevolence and mercy, forgiving each other as God in Christ forgave us (cf. Eph 4.31 to 32). And since our reconciliation derives from the sacrifice of Christ voluntarily dead for us, both the cross, placed as a main tree in the church to guide it in its navigation in the world35, the inspirer of our mutual relationships, so that all of them are truly Christian. From none of them is any personal renunciation absent. The result will be a fraternal openness to others, such as to make everyone’s abilities willingly recognized, and to allow everyone to give their contribution to the enrichment of the only ecclesial communion “so that everything and the individual parts are strengthened, communicating each with the others and agreeing to work for fullness”36. In this sense, it can be allowed that the well-understood unit allows everyone to develop their own personality.
This openness to others, supported by a desire for understanding and a capacity for renunciation, will permanently and neatly make that act of charity commanded by the Lord, which is fraternal correction (cf. Mt 18.15). Since this can be done by any believer to any brother in faith, it can be the normal means of healing many dissensions or preventing them from arising37. In turn, it pushes those who make it to remove the beam from their eye (cf. Mt 7.5), so that the order of the correction is not perverted38. And therefore the practice of the same is resolved in the principle of animation towards holiness, which alone can give reconciliation its fullness; which consists not of an opportunistic pacification that would mask the worst of enmities39, but in the inner conversion and unifying love in Christ that derives from it, which is carried out mainly in the sacrament of reconciliation, which is penance, through which the faithful “they receive from the mercy of God the forgiveness of the offenses made to him and together they reconcile with the church, to which they inflicted a wound with sin”40, provided that “this, .. sacrament of salvation … takes root throughout their lives and pushes them to a more fervent service of God and of the brothers”41.
However, it remains that “in the structure of the body of Christ there is a diversity of members and offices”42, and that this diversity causes inevitable tensions. They are also found in the saints, but not such as to kill concord, not such as to destroy charity43. How can we prevent them from degenerating into division? It is from that same diversity of people and functions that the sure principle of ecclesial cohesion derives. In fact, the pastors of the church, made up of Christ his ambassadors to the other faithful and endowed, for this reason, with an authority which, transcending the positions and options of individuals, all unifies them in the integrity of the gospel, which is precisely the “word of reconciliation” (cf. 2 Cor 5.18 to 20). The authority with which they propose it is binding not for acceptance by men, but for bestowal by Christ (cf. Mt 28.18; Mc 16.15 to 16; At 26,17s). For therefore, whoever listens or despises them listens or despises Christ and the one who sent him (cf. Lc 10.16), the duty of obedience of the faithful to the authority of pastors is an ontological requirement of the Christian being himself.
The pastors of the church, on the other hand, constitutionally form a single body undivided with Peter’s successor and in dependence on him; therefore the unity of faith and communion of all believers depends on the concordant fulfillment and faithful acceptance of their ministry44, manifestation to the world of reconciliation carried out by God in his church. May the common invocation to the Savior find fulfillment: “Always assist the college of bishops with our Pope; and grant them the gifts of unity, charity and peace”45. That sacred shepherds, as in an eminent and visible way represent Christ himself and take his place46, thus imitate and transfuse into the people of God the love with which he immolated himself: “he loved the church and gave himself up for her” (Eph 5.25). And let this be their renewed love, an effective example for the faithful, first of all for priests and religious, who had failed to meet the needs of their ministry and vocation, so that everyone in the church, “with one heart and one soul” (cf. At 4.32), return to be committed “to spreading the gospel of peace”. (Eph 6.15).
The mother church looks bitterly at the abandonment of some of her children awarded the ministerial priesthood or, with another special title, consecrated to the service of God and the brothers. However, he finds relief and joy in the generous perseverance of all those who remain faithful to their commitments with Christ and with the church; and, supported and comforted by the merits of this multitude, she also wants to convert the pain that has been brought to her in love that everything can understand and that everything can forgive in Christ.
Conclusion#
We, who as successors of Peter, certainly not for our personal merit, but by virtue of the apostolic mandate transmitted to us, are, in the church, visible principle and foundation of unity of sacred shepherds as well as of the multitude of faithful47, we appeal to the full restoration of the supreme good of reconciliation with God, within us and among us, so that the church may be an effective sign of union with God and unity among all his creatures in the world. This is a requirement of our faith in the church itself, “that in the Symbol we profess one, holy, catholic and apostolic”48. To love it, to follow it, to build it we all urgently avoid, making the words of S. our own. Augustine: “Love this church, be in such a church, be such a church”49.
It is the invitation that we address to all our children, especially to those who have the responsibility to guide the brothers, with this exhortation. We wanted it pastoral and full of trust, dictated by a spirit of peace. Perhaps, it may seem severe to someone. But it was born from a gaze thrown in depth on the situation of the church, on the one hand, and on the indispensable needs of the gospel, on the other. But it arose especially from our hearts: We have a duty to love the church with the same spirit as the allegory of the branch that must be pruned to bear greater fruit (cf. Gv 15.2). Finally, this exhortation is supported by a great hope, which the serious weight of our apostolic mandate has never altered. We are grateful to God’s faithfulness. We hope that the Holy Spirit will arouse an irresistible echo to our words: he is already present and active in the secret of the heart of each believer, and will lead everyone, in humility and peace, on the ways of truth and love. He is our strength. We know that the immense majority of the children of the church awaited such a call, and are prepared to welcome it with fruit. We hope that the whole people of God - it is our ardent vow - will keep up with us, as in the biblical journey with us, undertake the stages of sanctification of the jubilee, and be one with us, so that the world may believe;and let himself be guided by the grace of our lord Jesus Christ, by the love of God the Father, by the communion of the Holy Spirit.
We entrust these vows to the intercession of the immaculate Virgin “which shines as a model of virtue to the whole community of the elect …” and for her intimate participation in the history of salvation, somehow brings together and reverberates in itself the maximum data of faith50; and we comfort the common will of sanctification and reconciliation by heartily imparting our apostolic blessing.
Rome, at San Pietro, on the solemnity of the immaculate conception of b. v. Mary, December 8, 1974, the twelfth year of our pontificate.
PAOLO PP. VI
Footnotes#
See. AAS 65, 1973, pp. 323 s. ↩︎
See. Lumen Gentium, 3: AAS 57, 1965, p.6 ↩︎
Gaudium et Spes, 21: AAS 58, 1966, p.1041 ↩︎
See Bubble Apostolorum limina, 23 May 1974: AAS 66, 1974, p.306 ↩︎
S. LION M. Serm. 26, 5: PL 54, 215. ↩︎
CIR THEODORETE.Interpr. Epist. II ad Cor .: PG 82, 411 A. ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 7: AAS 57, 1965, p.9 ↩︎
S. AGOSTINOSerm. 96, 7, 8: PL 38, 588 ↩︎
S. IROLAMO In Epist. to Eph. 1, 2: PL 26, 504 ↩︎
S. HAMBROGIOIn Luc. 5, 58: PL 15, 1737 ↩︎
See S. YOUTH. CHRISOSTOMOIn Matth., Homil. 16, 9: PG 57, 250;S. ISIDORO PELUS. Epist. 4, 111:PG 78, 1178; NICOLAS CABASILAS.Explic. div. Liturg. 26, 2: Sourc. chrét. 4 bis, p. 171 ↩︎
S. CIRILLO ALESS. In Epist. II to Cor: PG 74, 943 D. ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 27: AAS 57, 1965, p. 32 ↩︎
See. Lumen Gentium, 11: AAS 57, 1965, p. 15 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 1: AAS 57, 1965, p.5 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 4: AAS 57, 1965, p.7 ↩︎
Gaudium et Spes, 43: AAS 58, 1966, p.1064 ↩︎
Unitatis Redintegratio, 3: AAS 57, 1965, p. 92 ↩︎
In Unitatis Redintegratio, 2 : AAS 57, 1965, p. 92 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 8: AAS 57, 1965, p. 11 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 8: AAS 57, 1965, p. 12 ↩︎
S. Giov. CHRISOSTOMO, In Epist. to Coloss. Homil. 3, 5: PG 62, 324 ↩︎
See. Dei Verbum, 10: AAS 58, 1966, p. 822 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 23: AAS 57, 1965, p. 29 ↩︎
S. AGOSTINO Epist. 187, 11, 34: PL 33, 845 ↩︎
See S. EFREM. STR. Comment. Evang. concord. 1, 18: Sourc. chrét. p. 52 ↩︎
See. Dei Verbum, 7: AAS 58, 1966, p. 820 ↩︎
Dei Verbum, 10: AAS 58, 1966, p. 822 ↩︎
Dei Verbum, 8: AAS 58, 1966, p. 820 ↩︎
See. Lumen Gentium, 9: AAS 57, 1965, p. 13 ↩︎
TERTULLIANO. Apologeticum XXXIX, 7; Corpus Christianorum, Series Latina, I, 1, p. 151 ↩︎
S. LION M. Tract. 84a, 2: Corpus Christ. 138 A, p. 530 ↩︎
S. AGOSTINO In I. Evang., 27, 6: PL 35, 1618 ↩︎
S. LION M. Serm. 26, 3: PL 54, 214 ↩︎
See S. MAXIMUM TOR. Serm. 37, 2: Corpus Christ. 23, p. 145 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 13: AAS 57, 1965, p. 17 s. ↩︎
See S. TOMMASO. Summa theol. II-IIæ, q. 33, a. 4: Opera omnia, Ed. Leon., T. VIII, p. 266 ↩︎
See S. BONAVENTURA. In IV Sent., dist. 19, dub. 4: Opera omnia, Ad Claras Aquas, t. IV, p. 512 ↩︎
See S. IROLAMO. Contra Pelagian. 2, 11: PL 23, 546 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 11: AAS 57, 1965, p. 15 ↩︎
Ordo Paenitentiae, Praenotanda, n. 7, Typis Polyglottis Vaticanis 1974, p. 14 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 7: AAS 57, 1965, p. 10 ↩︎
S. AGOSTINO. Enarrat. in Ps. 33, 19: PL 36, 318 ↩︎
Cfr. Pastor Aeternus, Prooem.: DS 3050; Lumen Gentium, 18: AAS 57***,*** 1965, p. 22. ↩︎
Liturgia Horarum, IV, Typis Polyglottis Vaticanis 1972, p. 513 ↩︎
Cfr. Lumen Gentium, 21: AAS 57, 1965, p. 25 ↩︎
Cfr. Lumen Gentium, 23: AAS 57, 1965, p. 27 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 8: AAS 57, 1965, p. 11 ↩︎
Serm. 138, 10: PL 38, 769 ↩︎
Lumen Gentium, 65: AAS 57, 1965, p. 64 ↩︎